Become a Nurse >> Browse Articles >> Step 2: Choose the Right Path
Where Are We On This Issue? ADN vs. BSN
Hollis Forster, RN
Twenty five years ago, nursing instructors told their students that in just a few years there would be no Associate degrees in nursing. All nurses who hoped to work as registered nurses would need to be Bachelor’s or Master’s trained.
Today, according to Nancy Tucker, Dean at Pacific Union College in Angwin, California, two thirds of nursing graduates every year complete their training with an AS (Associate of Science) or ADN (Associate Degree in Nursing) degrees. The Associate degree trained nurse persists, providing hospitals and out patient centers with proficiently trained nurses to manage their patient care. According to Ms. Tucker, there just are not enough graduates coming out of the BSN (Bachelor’s of Science in Nursing) programs to fill the needs of nursing across the state or the nation. Two year programs are here to stay, at least for the foreseeable future. The popularity of these programs is evidenced by the wait to enter these programs. In many schools across California, it can take two or three years to get to the top of the list to enter the nursing courses after completing general requirements. These programs are not only active, but thriving.
What about pay or advancement differentials? AS trained and BSN trained nurses are often treated equally in the hospital and out-patient setting. There are no substantial pay differentials, and nurses holding either degree have the same opportunities to become a charge nurse or director of a department.
So, what is the difference and how will it affect the course of a career in nursing? In today’s nursing world, more is expected from a nurse than following doctor’s orders and starting IVs. The nurse must be able to make critical decisions about a patient’s care, to question the doctor if orders seem inappropriate and to help the patient through, sometimes, difficult life-changing decisions. These skills take an education that is broad based, one that includes critical thinking and exposure to many different people, thought processes, and culture and societal norms. Two year nursing programs do recognize these needs and address them as they can, requiring liberal arts classes to be taken before entering the program and teaching decision making skills along the way. At every level of nursing, the ability to connect with different people, recognize the pressures they face from their personal environment and find value in each is critical. This is a lot to learn against a backdrop of proficiently performed procedures and giving the right medication.
What Can a BSN Get You?
BSN programs offer more education aimed at developing these skills. These programs bolster knowledge about community and public health issues. There is also more attention paid to nursing management, that is, enhancing skills needed to help “direct reports” do their best work for the patient and the health care organization. Opportunity to refine patient assessment skills and examine more in depth the patho-physiology of diseases, also sets these programs apart from their two-year sisters.
Nurses who graduate with a BSN degree will find it easier to enter faculty teaching positions, higher level administrative roles in hospitals or other health care environments and State or Federal level government nursing jobs. And for some, these roles are more satisfying, allowing the individual to affect change at a more global level than one-on-one nursing.
While it is true an experienced, talented nurse with an AS degree can move “up the ladder” into management and leadership roles, the Bachelor’s degree can make the climb a little less steep. And, with all this said, there will always be a critical role for the nurse who works directly with the patient, teaching patients about their health care, assuring quality wound management in the hospital setting and observing patients for signs of a worsening condition.
Nursing is a huge and welcoming field. It offers a satisfying career path for both AS and BSN trained nurses. Whatever path you have chosen in nursing, the essential wisdom is to continue enhancing your skills and education so that your community, your organization and your patients benefit from your broadened view of the world.
ADN vs. BSN? Click here to join the discussion!
EvangelisticSistah
about 1 year ago
92 comments
Seems this article answered my question for me...ADN is good enough for me to get started with atleast :)
suz7612002
about 1 year ago
4 comments
I was in a program at University of Phoenix, but had to drop due to family health issues. I wanted to start back up again, but I would have to take ALL of the courses again, even those I could now probably teach. Have decided to get a certificate as a Legal Nuse Consultant, and still work in my very nice, comfy job, doing my best every day and loving it. Any help with a fast paced BSN program with no BS?
tonigr32
about 1 year ago
8 comments
My best friend and I was just talking about this issue a couple of hours ago. Huge Thanks to the person that posted it. This article answered alot of questions I had.
teenzmom
about 1 year ago
2 comments
I have been an ADN nurse for over 20 yrs. I recently completed my BS. No difference in pay, and being able to function at a higher level straight from school made me choose ADN in the first place. Getting my BSN was more about me then it was about nursing. You learn on the job. If your goal is in research, or advanced practice, BSN is the way to go. If you are unsure, ADN provide a way to earn, and try out the field without the time and money invested. The title doesn't make you a better or worse nurse. Time in field and a genuine interst in learning does. There is a place for both, and we should respect and learn from each other
snowbunnyRN
about 1 year ago
258 comments
Thanks for this very interesting article. I'm 'on the fence' re: this subject. I'm considering returning to school for my BSN , because this seems to be the "preferred" nurse for opportunities for advancement in my facility. I agree that both the ADN and the BSN are similar with the pt skills. We work alongside each other as staff nurses.
treebabyblues
about 1 year ago
14 comments
After almost 20 years in the nursing field, I can say the most well trained nurses in patient care were LPN's that used to get 2000 hours on the floor in training.. The book smart people were BSN's. It seems that the lack of clinical experience and learning some of the most basic nursing skills were to be passed onto the staff nurses that have to orientate them to the acute care settings and train them how to insert foley's, do HS cares, morning cares, give an injection, etc. Some of these BSN's, who are to "lead" the floor or unit in the near future, don't have the ability to take what book smarts they have and apply it with some common sense situations. The ADN's instructors teach them more patient care skills and how to apply their knowledge to what they are seeing.
25 years ago, they told us no LPN schools would be around, ADN's would take the place of the LPN and then there would be no diploma nurses, only BSN's. Well, our diploma schools have changed to 4 year programs and we still have LPN and ADN programs. I think it's a shame that there isn't a better ladder in the field of nursing to climb up.
chattycathy
about 1 year ago
30 comments
I am graduating in 10 days with a ADN and I have found there is no difference in pay. I also have ehard that with a BSN that those students can write papers but lack the skills for patient care. With that being said, they are more marketable for managerial postions. I want to go to the ER after graduating and I want to learn there and not do a year of med/surg before I specialize. I went to school to use my knowledge, this could be why new grads leave the field all together.
mariejoe
about 1 year ago
4 comments
I have an AD in nursing in Texas as does my husband. We have both been managers, DON's, worked in hospitals ,home care, WAH, and other positions. Nurses working under us have been BSN , Masters , AD, and LVN's. Knowledge has varied with them all. Some of the ones with the least amount of knowledge were the most educated.
catfoodprincess
about 1 year ago
2 comments
A nicely done article, however, could we please stop using the term "trained". We train monkeys, we educate nurses. This is the mindset that will truely move us into the professional realm. We have much more responsibility than "training" could provide.
illusion466
about 1 year ago
8 comments
This is very well written and I really like the ladder analogy. It is very true. I have an AS and am back in school working on my BSN for the very same reasons mentioned in the article..
lclarke05
about 1 year ago
20 comments
This article really helps me put some things into perspective. That is a question i needed to be answered and this is very clear, thats to the person who posted this!