News >> Browse Articles >> Hospitals
News >> Browse Articles >> Scandals
Whistleblower Nurse Faces Charges for Exposing Abuse of Elderly Patients
Undercover: Nurse Margaret Haywood exposed 'despicable' neglect at a hospital (Central News)
Daily Mail
April 20, 2009
A nurse who exposed appalling neglect of the elderly at an NHS hospital began a fight to save her career today.
Margaret Haywood, 58, faces a series of disciplinary charges over a secret film she made for a BBC Panorama programme.
If a Nursing and Midwifery Council panel finds against her, she could be struck off the nursing register.
The veteran nurse was hired to help investigate concerns about the Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton.
She and reporter Shabnam Grewal gathered evidence of failures to give even basic care to frightened and dying elderly patients.
One was left to die alone while others spent hours in their own filth or with nothing to drink. Some were in agony from a lack of pain relief.
After one shift Haywood said: ‘I can honestly say it is the worst ward I have ever, ever worked on.’
The documentary ’ Undercover Nurse’, shown on BBC 1 in July 2005, sparked an investigation by Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, which issued a public apology admitting ‘serious lapses in the quality of care’.
The Central London hearing was told that Haywood admitted breaching confidentiality by passing contact details for patients and their families to programme makers.
She told interviewers: ‘That is a chance I am willing to take for things to improve. Hopefully I will not lose my registration. If I do, it is a small price to pay for things to get better.’
gracy03
over 1 year ago
26 comments
I salute you Ms Haywood !!!!
TsalagiTsagi
over 1 year ago
8 comments
I think everyone is hopefully appalled by the abuse / neglect of any patient anywhere.
I think the legal issue is more complex in this case. Most countries have channels one goes through when someone in the medical profession suspects neglect or abuse. These channels should be known and adhered to by every medical professional. It is the nurses responsibility to protect their patients.
By accepting pay to "expose" this hospitals alleged wrong doing, she may have delayed the intervention by the proper authorities and that may be the issue. Not that word finally got out but that it was delayed and patients were allowed to be at risk even though she knew they were being poorly protected and cared for. Advocacy should be immediate to stop the abuse.
Cameras, still or video must never be used to photograph a patient without their own, their guardian or their POAs written consent. That is a breach of trust and confidentiallity.
There is not much doubt that disciple will be a part of this terrible heartbreaking situation.
restless_lpn
over 1 year ago
4 comments
I do agree she did the right thing. But she should have went the chain of command . There seems so much more to this story. Like a paitent dying alone, if she was there why didn't she go. I guess I am just lost in this story. (sorry)
sonsoucie3
over 1 year ago
12 comments
im just a certified nurse aide and certified meication tech but i have been fired from several jobs for reorting abuse and neglect! isnt OUR JOB TO REPORT THAT THATS WHAT THEY TEACH YOU IN CLASS AND BESIDES THAT YOU WOULDNT SLAP YOURE OWN GRANDPARENT OR MAKE THEM LYE IN FILTH AND STARVE BUT IT HAPPENS MORE THAN U CAN IMAGINE!MY HAT IS OFF TO THAT NURSE FOR STANDING UP AND I KNOW FIRST HAND HOW SHES BEEN BLACKBALLED BY THE NURSING BOARD AND IT DOES SUK LOSING YOURE LICENSE FOR DOING THE JOB THAT YOU ARE HIRING AND TRAINED TO DO AND HER TAKING THE EXTRA STEP TO GO BEHIND THE SCENES WELL YOU GO GIRL!!!
catty0009
over 1 year ago
44 comments
my hat is off to you nurse Haywood.....I think it is great...I truly would hate to see you lose your license as well as all the other nurses, and if I was in that position you are, I doubt I would care either if it brought some changes......the place where I have worked at has been in the news and on the front page as well for abuse of the infirmed and at times, it has been swept under the rug, but this last time, there were some arrests......at times, just going by chain of command will not get a person anywhere, esp if they dont want to see their favorites getting in trouble.....I am glad that you were able to sit up and say enough is enough.....
pbeck
over 1 year ago
4 comments
Nurse Haywood did the right thing for those vulnerable patients. I wish more nurses would stand up for patient rights and stop the abuse of the elderly. If you don't report the abuse you are just as quilty of the atrocities. Every nurse should be trained on how to recognize and report abuse promptly and immediately take that patient out of harms way.
barbiebearden
over 1 year ago
2 comments
She did the right thing. Her first ethical and moral responsibility as a nurse is to be an advocate for the patient, especially under such conditions when there is no one to speak for these people and evidently no accountability for the care taking institution. Violation of the privacy issues under these dire and immoral circumstances should fall under amnesty rights for reporting human rights violations. It is also the same as when a therapist or a MD must report child abuse or harm to the patient or another even though it falls under the same privacy acts. To not report this would be a criminal, ethical and moral mistake. She should be applauded and the laws modified not to gag professionals that need to protect and advocate for the clients and patients. I am sure those dying patients left in their filth in agony are not going to sue over breach of privacy issues. Let's get our priorities straight.
Tolulope
over 1 year ago
186 comments
The whole scene appears complicated with the contrasting edge of good advocacy to the professional dilemma faced.
Haven't we got to review this?
tschoolmom
over 1 year ago
2 comments
I'm glad there,s another whistle blower besides me. I'm a cna and a while ago i seen another aide hit a patient, which i told and they ran an investigation, and she was let go. i also told on another aide at another nursing home to, but they just sent her to a different floor for a month,then she was right back on the same floor, i don't understand. i hope everything goes well for you i applaud you for standing up sometimes it takes serious action to get the right things done good luck
Shan4691
over 1 year ago
6784 comments
it's terible that such a great pateint advocate may loose her job and career.
mammadukes1
over 1 year ago
8 comments
YOU GO GIRL, SOME NEEDS TO STEP UP TO THE PLATE, I APPALUADE YOU AND YOUR COURAGE, AS JOYCE MYERES WOULD SAY (DON'T GIVE UP)
tbradley
over 1 year ago
2 comments
omg! so the abuse was to keep going on? im glad she is willing to put her job on the line for the rights of those poor patients. its really sad though that people can even do that to others, abuse them. im a cna @ a nursing home, and if see abuse of any kind im reporting it. i really wouldnt care who id make mad. the elderly are important too. just think, everyone will eventually be there, and i sure wouldnt wan to be treated like that. i hope she doesnt lose her license over this, that would be wrong! i say thanks margaret.
athenawarren
over 1 year ago
14 comments
Hip-Hip-Hooray!! A Nurse that actually stands up for her patients-not just says the words!!!
deannedawn75
over 1 year ago
10 comments
My hat off to Margret Haywood. There needs to be more nurses that avocated for their patients, especially elderly ones.
sandmtnms
over 1 year ago
4 comments
Three cheers for Margaret Haywood. Nurses take an oath they they will be advocates for their patients, but not enough of us are ready to put our job on the line to do it. Iam a nurse in AL which is a so-called "right to work" state. In actually, this means that employers have a right to FIRE and do not have to have any valid reason to do so. I worked for two diferent hospice organizations and reported problems with administration policies and quality of patient care and I was fired both times. The attorneys I talked to said it is almost impossible to win a "wrongful termination" in this state, so I just had to move on and try to explain myself when interviewing for other RN positions.
I did feel that I accomplished something, though, because a week after I left the first position the head honchos for the company came in to investigate the local office and the administrator was demoted. In the second case, it took quite a bit longer, until the company was bought out, then my administrator at that hospice was given the choice to be demoted to staff RN of leave. Last I heard she was a staff RN at a rural hospital. I hope Ms. Haywood stands by her convictions. Moral and ethical values and fighting for what you know is right are more important than any job. ALabama RN.