Everything Nurses >> Nurse Talk >> Mother left to perform CPR on baby while paramedic drove ambulance

Rate

Mother left to perform CPR on baby while paramedic drove ambulance

590 Views
10 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Photo_user_blank_big

93 posts

back to top

Posted over 5 years ago

 

A Tokoroa mother was forced to perform CPR on her baby in the back of an ambulance this week when the vehicle arrived with only one officer.

The baby later died at Tokoroa Hospital.

A close family member, who did not want to be identified, said the family called the ambulance on Monday morning when the baby boy had difficulty breathing.

"The St John ambulance turned up with only one lady," the woman said.

"She drove the ambulance to the hospital while the mother of the baby did CPR in the back." The woman said the incident raised questions about why the ambulance was staffed by only one person, leaving a distressed mother to perform CPR.

"I would have thought the ambulance officer would do that," she said.

"Why even bother calling the ambulance if the mother is going to do CPR?

"This issue needs to be dealt with. I'm really angry.

"You call the ambulance because you trust them when you're sick."

She said the death had been "very upsetting" for the family.

They were preparing for the baby's tangi.

St John Ambulance regional operations manager Brent Nielsen today explained the circumstances surrounding the incident.

He said a single-crewed ambulance was sent to the emergency, and a call was placed to a back-up officer who was immediately sent to the scene.

It took nine minutes between emergency staff receiving the call and the ambulance leaving the baby's house to take him to Tokoroa Hospital, 500m away.

Mr Nielsen said the second officer met the ambulance "moments after it had left the scene" and took over the driving, leaving the first officer free to resume CPR on the baby for the remainder of the trip.

The ambulance arrived at the hospital two minutes after leaving the baby's house.

Mr Nielsen said the person at the scene agreed to assist with CPR, adding that at emergency situations where CPR was needed, it was common for more than one person to perform the procedure to ensure the patient received continuous care.

St John's position on emergency responses was that all ambulances should be double crewed wherever possible.

"Single crewing is never a matter of choice it is a matter of available resources," Mr Nielsen said.

"All emergency responses in New Zealand should be fully crewed. St John is focused on achieving 100 per cent full crewing for all emergency ambulances."

Sometimes full crewing was not possible, due to the unavailability of resources (either paid or volunteer), or a higher than usual number of callouts in one area, Mr Nielsen said.

It was better to send a single-crewed vehicle than no vehicle at all, or to wait for one to come from further away.

Mr Nielsen said St John wished to express its condolences to the family.

Photo_user_blank_big

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

In the first half of the article, you get angry yourself, "Why even bother calling the ambulance if the mother is going to do CPR? This issue needs to be dealt with. I’m really angry. You call the ambulance because you trust them when you’re sick.” I cannot imagine the parents grief, but at first I was angry at the paramedic outfit, but when you read the rest, you get the full story and you can't blame anyone really. It's just a horrendously tragic event.

Nana_and_grandkids_minus_noah_max50

5939 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

nursingaround: I agree with you completely. I was so angry at first but then when the true situation was revealed, it calmed my anger but made me very sad that this could happen. It was horrible enough for the mother to experience her child to stop breathing but to be added to that she had do CPR on her on chld as well was just unbelievable. How many Mothers would be calm enough to be able do that ? Changes should be made to the ambulance company requiring 2 crew members at all times. Unfortunately, it takes something as tragic as this to open people's eyes and do something about these situations.. Perhaps community fund raisers could supply the ambilance company with additional funds. All avenues of resource should be investigated.

Photo_user_blank_big

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

And that is the problem with small towns in the back country in New Zealand, staffing. We are a small country, with a modern medical system, but we almost don't have enough people for the area we have. I'm happy with all that space, but it sometimes has a cost, and this is an example of it.

Dscf0350_max50

628 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

In the United States, many rural areas have volunteer fire companies who often respond to medical emergencies. The volunteer fire fighters are usually trained in CPR and can drive ambulances. This provides EMS with a valuable manpower resource when necessary. Does New Zealand have anything similar?

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I have a really good friend, who lives in New Zealand. Over the past few years, she has sent me news articles, websites, etc showing me the decline in available healthcare options for the Maori and other poor factions. For some very strange reason, the powers that be in New Zealand have changed from publicly funded healthcare to model itself after the United States healthcare system. New Zealand has gone from a very good, publicly funded healthcare to a poor one. Particularly the Maori have suffered, along with disabled and non disabled people, both Maori and non Maori who can't afford the private health insurance model. I think this is just another part of New Zealand's declining healthcare system

Photo_user_blank_big

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

Not sure about your source, but all hospital treatment is free. The big cost is at the traditional family doctor. Many people, not just low income people, struggle with the family doctor bill. An average visit to the family doctor, including prescriptions cost around $100/visit. Children up to 5 or 6 are free, at least it used to be. But it is nothing like the states.
I don't know that the the focus is on a decline for Maori, there certainly isn't a deliberate goal to target a certain ethnic group, when it is a decline for everyone. Most nurses and friends I know don't have private health care insurance, this is the norm.
The problem though is that the waiting lists are ridiculous, sometimes six months or even a year, just for a consult. Some people choose to pay the initial consult fee, just to speed up the process, then have the rest done with public healthcare.
The frustrating thing it that for year upon year the government has had record budget surpluses, but it's not really filtering down to the hospitals, at least not that we can see.

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I only know what I've read, viewed online and what she tells me. She's a political activist for the disabled, well known in NZ. She's also part Maori, so I would suspect she sees things far differently than a non Maori.

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

One crew member is unacceptable. I run as a volunteer with my communities Rescue Squad. I am the Asst. Chief there. We do not roll a truck unless there are two on the Ambulance. One driver and one EMT. If two members cannot respond and only one does, that one goes to the scene , BY POV. They can assist untill another service can get a ambulance there to take over. Yes I have responded solo and rode with family to the hospital, POV, while doing CPR. We met the next community Fire medics and local ambulance service enroute and continued to the hospital. Never have we had the family to handle our JOB. That is just irresponsiblity on behave of the ambulance service in NZ.

Hpim0228_max50

24 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I think the hospital made the better of two bad decision choices. They sent the ambulance. I think they would face more blame, had they waited for another ambulance to arrive. Since the baby got to the hospital within two minutes, there might have been other complications, that a paramedic doing CPR could not rectify

This is a big loss for the family, and I am sure the paramedic wish that there was something she could do, but I don't think they should be blamed in this case. They did what they had to under the circumstances, and I applaud them for that.