General Forums >> Ask A Nurse >> Poll: Is Nursing a Profession or a Trade?

+2

Poll: Is Nursing a Profession or a Trade?

7,205 Views
26 Replies Flag as inappropriate

Poll: Is nursing a trade or profession?

Editornurse_max50

90 posts

back to top

Posted over 2 years ago

 

What distinguises a trade from a profession? This week's question touches on the subject of nurses gaining the recognition they deserve. While LPNs and RNs hold degrees from varying institutions, we want to know if it's your degree that defines your profession or you. The head nurse wants to know:


Is nursing a trade or a profession, and what makes you a professional? Can having a particular degree change how someone perceives you and your skills?


Show your community members what your job really means and don't forget to vote on the poll up above!


Lastly, check out this article discussing the differences between trades and professions in regards to nursing:


http://nursinglink.monster.com/benefits/articles/8452-is-nursing-a-...


 


 


 

Photo_user_blank_big

211 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

of course is a profession.


leena alkhatib

Photo_user_blank_big

187 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

I consider nursing to be a profession however, my last boss looked at me one day and said, "you know, we are nothing more than blue collar workers."  Yes, she did.  And she is currently continueing her education to become a Nurse Practitioner.  I don't agree with her.  I feel that nursing is a profession because of the education required along with the ability to think not only about medical issues but also, cultural variances, budgetary issues as well as reimbursement, biohazard, and body mechanics etc. before we have to make many many instant decsions in order to complete our 'jobs'.  ie, save lives, be a nurse, function.  I don't see how this could be considered a trade, but some do.

Beach_2007_079_max50

11 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

For myself nursing is a profession.  I feel a deep commitment to the patients under my care, whether they are assigned to me or simply admitted on my floor, or anywhere in my hospital.  I have the training to do the work and the knowledge and understanding to do it safely and well.  I feel the drive to try my best to care for not only the patient's diagnosis but also his/her fears, emotions, and other needs, along with the family who's hovering at the bedside nervously waiting on any news.  However, I also believe that as in many other professions, there are those who enter into the nursing field who view it only as a job and treat it as such. 

John_001_max600_max50

2085 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Nursing is a profession. Nurses have worked hard over the years to make it a profession.


I really am surprised that Nursing Link would have an article that even suggests that it is a trade. Part of the article said that working the floor is a trade while advancing to the ICU is a profession. The ICU nurses work the floor. So what does that make them, a professional trade? Nursing is just as much a profession as being a physician is.


I am not a nurse tradesman.


I am proud to be a professional nurse.


John L. Racher RN, BSN, MSRN-BC
nursejohn@ymail.com
Relaxation Consulting
Writing Therapy

One should study Philosophy, Archeology and History: Because
being confronted by the past, changes one's sense of the present.

-1 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Clearly, nursing is a calling and a distinct profession, especially registered nurses. Anyone who goes to go through so much educational preparation, personal sacrifice, numerous clinicals, HESI exam to obtain nursing deree, NCLEX to obtain nursing license, and cannot have any blemishes on your criminal background must be the nursing profession! Registered nurses are the ones everyone turns to, the hub of the healthcare wheel. I carry myself as a professional which further promotes our nursing profession and registered nurses. We cannot let the stress of the moment to erode our professionalism as we are modeling professional behaviors to others who work side by side with us. Affiliation with professional organizations is yet another way to further our profession and clearly be recognized as high-esteemed medical professionals.

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Of course nursing is a profession. I think anyone that sees nursing as a trade is wrong.  We go to school to learn everything there is about the human body and how to act if anything should go wrong. It seems as though anyone can say they are a mechanic but not everyone can say they are a nurse. We are trained to save lifes,ensure care and  even at times to maintain sustain life. We can't practice nursing without the proper credentials and without the states say so can't be a nurse. (Nclex) So how can anyone think of a nurse as just a blue collar worker or a trade. Sounds obsurd to me.

Photo_user_blank_big

23 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

 Nursing is a profession. All of the nurses no matter what your level of achievement is we all are professionals.

C

45 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

If an avocation requires extensive education ,then requires logical and reason together with good will, a caring attitude, humanitarian considerations, and the application of all of the aforementioned, it is a profession. Such being the case, nursing is a profession.

Photo_user_blank_big

1 post

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

A professional nurse uses her education and knowledge to make independent decisions and to react to patient problems and effect outcomes.  In a trade, one is trained to follow a certain procedure for a particular situation.  Nurses are professionals.

Photo_user_blank_big

1 post

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted over 2 years ago

 

I have always wanted to be a professional within healthcare.  I am not a nurse as of yet but I am working towards it; and I will get there. 


In my opinion nursing is a profession and always will be and not a trade.  I would think a trade is you learn a specific job and you just do it.  With nursing you continuously have to keep yourself abreast.  I work in a hospital and the nurse's their  have classes to update themselves of changes within  so how can that be a trade.


I'm surprise that it would be a topic.


 


 

Photo_user_blank_big

273 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

" It is most certainly a profession. People who truly enjoy taking care of people of all ages may consider nursing,


   " a profession", though their are many that consider," only the select few, professional,"( RN,not LPN).


      " Over the course of many years, I have worked with and encountered several persons,fortunate enough


       to be in positions of leadership,however, should have never been allowed the opportunity to do so.


        ( "I will spare the details".) There are numerous persons who have proven their worth,with regards to ,


        " going above and beyond the call of duty,exceptional in performance,yet they were lucky enough to be,


        "given a comforting smile or thank you".The true professional,( RN / LPN / CNA ), who does their job,


         is clearly visible on the unit and ," takes the initiative,helping when help is needed", is the professional."


     

Photo_user_blank_big

13 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

cheetah5


I am appauld that anyone would even consider this a trade. This is most defenitly a profession, I am a Professional Nurse not a trade nurse. I dedicate my career to helping my patients. When they ask you on any forms it is what profession are you looking for not what trade.

Photo_user_blank_big

1 post

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

 It is a profession


 


 


Keith Kohl

968_ask_an_rn_logo_max50

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

I would confidently say that nursing is a profession. In Indonesia, my homecountry, Nursing considered as a profession since it has a strong basic knowledge. Morever, we have a regulation which state that Bachelor Degree nurses are considered as professionals.


 


However, I think that what make us professional is not necessarily our degree. It is us who should show them (the society) that nurses are indeed professional. We can gain respect and acknowledgement from them when we show them what we are capable to do.




Indeed, it is not an easy thing to do. But I believe, us, nurses, are professional. Thus, we should act professionally.

0 posts

back to top
-5

Rated: -5 | Posted over 2 years ago

 

in my opion, it can be a profession, but really it's a trade.  I work in a hospital & the nurses of course are going to say it's a profession, but to me it's a trade only because if u see what i see only a few can consider themselves professional.  i'm not a nurse, but the only thing i don't do is  pass meds.  i do trach care, bandage changes, work with hospice in comfort care, ekgs, draw am labs (blood).  am & pm care. Most nurses that i see can't even put in an iv.  They call the iv team or to draw blood they call me.  Patient care associate.(pca).  The nurses are to buzy doing care plans & paper work to cover there buts when it comes to giving meds.  Some are even being investigated for taking the meds themselves.  So u will see only the nurses themselves think it's a profession, but me a pca think that most nurses only get in the profession for the money because it's the shortest corse of school 2 yrs. not realizing the work it really involves.  I see nurses breaking down and crying, walking off the job, because they just can't handle the work load of having a full work load of 6,7,or 8 patients at a time.  for chris sake what the hell did they expect when they took on the job of being a nurse?

Photo_user_blank_big

1 post

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

 Nursing is a profession,from the founder Florence night gale nursing has always been a profession,a calling dedicated to help the sick,injured and infirm.Trade has a clear line of advertising for their products.

Photo_user_blank_big

9 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Nursing is definitly a profession!  Otherwise, almost anyone could hold themselves out to be a nurse!  After years of stydying and doing one should consider themselves a professional and act like one.

Photo_user_blank_big

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Staffing issues begin with not having enough support staff to do real nursing (if an RN has to give a bath, change a wound dressing and administer medications, teach the patient, interpret doctor's orders, transcribe the orders, double check pharmacy's transcription of the MAR, call the results of reports to the doctor, AND still be liable for the patient's safety when the one responsible for the mistake is off the hook for not being the last person in the line sure makes nursing attractive, huh! Wonder why there's a nursing shortage.  Add to that a decrease in the quality of the education of nurses, its no wonder we have seen and increase in errors by nurses! In response to errors automated systems, bar-coding etc has been implemented.  Instead of increasing the knowlege base and supporting nurses,  we are relying on automation - soon all you will need is a bar code and a computer and a body - doesn't sound like the move is to make nurses a profession...BURNED OUT

Photo_user_blank_big

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Staffing issues begin with not having enough support staff to do real nursing (if an RN has to give a bath, change a wound dressing and administer medications, teach the patient, interpret doctor's orders, transcribe the orders, double check pharmacy's transcription of the MAR, call the results of reports to the doctor, AND still be liable for the patient's safety when the one responsible for the mistake is off the hook for not being the last person in the line sure makes nursing attractive, huh! Wonder why there's a nursing shortage.  Add to that a decrease in the quality of the education of nurses, its no wonder we have seen and increase in errors by nurses! In response to errors automated systems, bar-coding etc has been implemented.  Instead of increasing the knowlege base and supporting nurses,  we are relying on automation - soon all you will need is a bar code and a computer and a body - doesn't sound like the move is to make nurses a profession...BURNED OUT

Photo_user_blank_big

3 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

I think there is confusion on the trade / profession question when it comes to unions.  They are TRADE unions.  True professionals will work even when it is not compensated.  But then again, what about the bosses up in the offices?  They are professionals who also don't act professionally--meaning on equal grounds with other professionals.  Have you ever seen a CEO yell or scream at a plumber as he is fixing a toilet?  No they are grateful that someone else can do that job.  And plumbers are paid more than nurses most of the time.  Yes, I know the official stance is about a governing body, but the awful hours, the higher demands for productivity (carrying more sicker patients) make me feel that I am "just" in a trade. 

Owl_max50

43 posts

back to top
+2

Rated: +2 | Posted over 2 years ago

 

It is, of course, a profession. A profession which has yet to come in to its own. By this I refer to the need for a National Nursing License, in the same way that we have ONE U.S. Passport, ONE Drivers' License which allows one to move freely from state to state and finally, the need for a strong and unified national nursing association which seizes the same political and social power which doctors grabbed so long ago. The American Medical Association was referred to by the Wall Street Journal 30 years ago as 'one of the most powerful LABOR UNIONS in America.' There is no reason that nurses should not attain the same distinction to replace the divisiveness which 'keeps us down' from being recognized in the same fashion as is our rightful due if only we could admit that we must stick together in order to achieve the status that we deserve.

Photo_user_blank_big

9 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

It is quite professional and not a trade . But the present conditions in our working areas


making us to consider it as a trade.

Photo_user_blank_big

100 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

A Trade plain and simple. How many other "professionals" are paid hourly, get called off at the drop of a hat, and basically perform "tasks" all day long? Wake up people we are a Trade and should be unionized so that we have a say in how things go. One other thing about this article ticks me off, when I was an LPN I wasn't a nurse, now that I have an Assoc. degree the article implies that Im less of a nurse than someone with a BSN. Please tell me when I will be a "real nurse" because obviously up til now I have spent a lot of money for nothing.........Nurses: "Responsible for everything, with power over nothing"

-33 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

I guess since I'm a lawyer I should at least explain the legal answer to this:


By New Jersey State law and court decision, an RN is a professional and also "management" (even when assigned to a non-management position.


An RN license here reads "Registered Professional Nurse."


An LPN license reads "Licensed Practical Nurse." LPN's attend trade school. So, at least in this State LPN's work in a trade.


Yes I know lots of bright LPN's who in certain facilities do almost exactly what RN's do, and are sometimes much better at it!


But I'm just giving you the Legal definitions...

Bettyboop_max50

764 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 2 years ago

 

Thank you, Captain for that info. I'm sure a lot of us were not aware of the legal definitions.  You always have such great info to share with all of us!


I looked up the definitions of both in Merriam-Websters dictionary, here is what I found


Profession:  a calling requiring specialized knowledge and often long and intensive academic preparation


                        a principal calling, vocation, or employment


Trade:   the business or work in which one engages regularly : occupation


               an occupation requiring manual or mechanical skill : craft


               the persons engaged in an occupation, business, or industry 


Based on these definitions, I would be inclined to say that nursing is a professional trade.  Clearly nursing takes intensive academic  preparation and is a calling, but it is also an occupation that requires manual skill and is a craft.  Not everyone is cut out to be a nurse, and how many times have we heard people say, "Oh, you're a nurse??  I could never do that!"


 


 


~ Laugh as much as you breath and love as long as you live ~