Career Corner >> Nursing Specialization >> Does Hiring Supplemental/Temporary Nurses Lower Standards?

Rate

Does Hiring Supplemental/Temporary Nurses Lower Standards?

414 Views
5 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Char_syringe_max50

388 posts

back to top

Posted almost 6 years ago

 

According to a recent article, health care quality is not lessened by hiring temp nurses. Is this study accurate? What has been your experience with supplemental/temporary nurses?

Photo_user_blank_big

33 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I'm offended by this question. How or why would anyone think that a temporary nurse is somehow less qualified than a regular full time staff? I'm a travel nurse. I went to an accredited school of nursing with a GPA scale higher than most schools, and I graduated cum laude even there. I passed boards the first time 'round and have never had anything but exemplary evaluations in my nursing. I pass competencies 4 times a year as a traveller instead of the the usual 1 time a year a regualar staff nurse does. Why would anyone assume I'm less qualified or competent in my work as a nurse or that my work lessens nursing standards. I think this whole notion, which I often encounter, comes from inept nurses who know they are inept and subsequently lack the confidence in their careers to to do anything other than criticize those they perceive as weak, like the new kid on the block-- the agency or travel nurse. I worked as a regular staff nurse for years before becoming a travel, or agency nurse, and I have to say that I have to be much more adept and flexible as an agency than any staff nurse has to be. A staff nurse can very easily get complacent and work from habit, without considering new or better ways of accomplishment. An agency has constantly to learn new ways, and will by nature, constantly evaluate what is efficient and what isn't--because of comparing and contrasting. Right now I'm on a temporary assignment where the manager actually likes hearing my different experiences, and what has worked to solve some problem somewhere else-- and I feel very fortunate to have that manager. Most do not want to hear it. Most want to keep the very inefficient, wasteful status quo. I'm hoping to use all the ways I've seen and learned either to open my own staffing business (with policies I develop myself) or go into management after I've had more of a chance to compare and contrast various practices. I think the real question should be, "Does NOT hiring temporary supplemental staffing lower nursing standards." Let staff nurses not become so complacent in their sometimes very narrowly defined ways, adamant to reisist any change at all, even if it's for the better of patients and nurses. And for those who wonder if I'm speaking the truth, prove yourself as a nurse every 3 months instead of every year. See how much fun it is.

Rebel_alliance__star_wars__-_wikipedia__the_free_encyclopedia_max50

628 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

Agency, travel or contract nurses have the same impact on the nursing care at a facility as the actual staff, whether it be good or bad. Interviews are often a crap-shoot. You do the best to hire good nurses into your staff and you do your best to screen the best travelers. Sometimes it works and sometimes you get burned. One plus with travelers is that when you find out they aren't what they were billed to be or can't handle the load, you can terminate the contract. It's a much more difficult process with your own staff. Basically, whether you're agency or staff, if you suck, you suck. The agency nurses we have most recently used, and extended, were excellent. I am truly sorry to see them go.

Photo_user_blank_big

1 post

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

Thank you for clarifying that. I am interested in becoming a travel nurse after graduating from school and being a staff nurse for a year of experience. I appreciate both of your inputs.

Nana_and_grandkids_minus_noah_max50

5939 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I am a temp nurse and I agree with Kay-why would a temp nurse be any less qualified than a staff nurse? I think we have to be more flexible and on the ball to fit into a given setting at a moments notice. I have been a nurse for 27 yrs. with varied nursing experiences that I bring to each job. I don't understand why this should even be an issue. Especially with the nursing shortage, I'm sure you'll be seeing alot more of the temp nurse. See ya!