General Forums >> Ask A Nurse >> LPN OR SURGICAL TECH?

Rate

LPN OR SURGICAL TECH?

4,268 Views
8 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Hpim0705_max50

5 posts

back to top

Posted almost 5 years ago

 

Hello!  I have a question for those of you already out there in the profession. I'm a 50 year old female, retiring from the military. I have always wanted to get into the medical profession and now that my kids are grown, I'm going to. My question, which job is better, LPN or Surgical Tech?  I find surgery facinating (I'm addicted to medical shows on discovery channel) and there is a 11 month surgical Tech program at a local hospital I've looked into. Gives me my certification and lets me take the national test.  There are also several Vocational schools with LPN programs, I worry I will do nothing but work in a nursing home, but working in a doctors office sounds intresting or being a school nurse (if school nurses are LPNs and not RNs?) would be great to me.  Any opinions on which job would be better?  I teach Buddy care for the military (basically triage, additional duty, not my job) and find that pretty intresting too, but emt's do not make alot in Indiana.  Any advice would be appreciated!  Thanks!

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

OR techs are in great demand across the country.  They make more money than an LPN/LVN with call time.  The OR is an exciting place to be, always something new and exciting to learn.  Also, after two years experience, there are many travel opportunites, if you'd be interested in traveling.   As an LPN there are not nearly as many opportunities out there I'm very sad to say.

Hpim0705_max50

5 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

Thanks dmazment for the input.  This is a tough decision for me, I'm really learning more toward the OR Tech, just because it's more intresting to me, but on allnurses.com, the answers I got all told me that OR tech would lock me into the same old job and LPN would give me more opportunites. I was suprised by those thoughts, your answer is more what I was thinking.  I had noticed the pay scale seemed higher for the OR tech, a friend who is a CNA told me a LPN is treated as a well paid CNA in most hospitals. I don't know if that's true. It shouldn't be if it is!  Thanks again, have a great day!

Nana_and_grandkids_minus_noah_max50

5939 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

greenie101-it's not true that LPNs are treated like" well-paid CNAs". In fact, nothing could be farther from the truth. I am a LPN and have been for 27 years. LPNs can do pretty much the same things RNs do. But they usually work under a RN. Sometimes, tho, as in nursing homes, they can be the Charge Nurse. Their duties are many and varied, depending on what type of nursing you do.  Dispensing medications, wound care, contacting MDs and obtaining orders, startng IVs, trach care-these are just a few as well as sometimes assuming or assisting with CNA duties if the need arises. I love being a LPN. There is a world of difference between a LPN and OR tech. You have to decide which one you are better suited for. The LPN is a bedside nurse with constant patient contact and interaction with the patient, the patient's family and the doctors (as well as other medical resourses-therapists, dietiticians etc.) . It's one on one care. While the OR tech is a specialized medical personnel who assists with the surgery and has little contact with the patient except during the surgery. But I think it would be very interesting and it pays a great deal more than LPN. However, being a LPN can be very rewarding. (that's my 2 cents worth!)  Good luck in whatever you decide!

Hpim0705_max50

5 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

Thanks charlita, I started looking into some LPN programs, problem with Indiana is all of their nursing programs are full time, during the day.  I did find an online LPN course in Minnesota. you do the schooling on line, then they break the clinicals down so that you go a week at a time. But I can't get them to give me exact info on that, they havn't yet set the schedule. It sounds doable, even having to travel to another state a few times in a semeseter to get clinicals done.


Your input helped, thanks so much! 

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

greenie101 says ...



Thanks dmazment for the input.  This is a tough decision for me, I'm really learning more toward the OR Tech, just because it's more intresting to me, but on allnurses.com, the answers I got all told me that OR tech would lock me into the same old job and LPN would give me more opportunites. I was suprised by those thoughts, your answer is more what I was thinking.  I had noticed the pay scale seemed higher for the OR tech, a friend who is a CNA told me a LPN is treated as a well paid CNA in most hospitals. I don't know if that's true. It shouldn't be if it is!  Thanks again, have a great day!



whoever is talking to you on allnurses.com apparently doesn't know what they're talking about.  Each surgeon does things differently, there is always new equiptment, new procedures, new things to learn in the OR. 

Happy_little_elf2_max50

238 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

I'll share my very limited experience...


1) Two of the three hospitals in my (rural) area no longer hire LPNs. I'm not sure why administration chooses to make that decision. Within the scope of practice, they perform many more tasks than a CNA. However, I was surprised to see many CNAs performing tasks that I learned within my first year of nursing school.


2) When I had my OR clinical, I was surprised to observe that the surgical tech is the surgeon's "right-hand-man". As the tech you are so involved with the surgery itself. A fellow student nurse thought about quitting the ADN program to pursue surgical tech because it interested her so much (she opted against it since she had one year of the two year program already completed). You must be able to stand in one area for a long time. I observed the OR as a team of people who treated each other like family and knew each other very well, since they are rather isolated together for long periods of time. In my humble opinion, it was a great working environment to observe.


In my school, both LPN and surgical tech require one year of school. Historically, surgical tech makes more (again in WI).


Best of luck to you in making your decision. I commend you for returning to school to pursue your dream!!! (And THANK YOU for your service to our country.)

Hpim0705_max50

5 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted almost 5 years ago

 

Thanks RN2B, both for your comments and for your compliment for my service to our country. :)  It's been alot of years and the military life is great, but changing rapidly...I am ready to call it quits, it's a young womans game and a very different game from when I went in in 1978! (yes, I"m old.haha)


Intresting perspective on the OR tech. Most replies I got on the allnurses site were pro for LPN/con against or Tech, simply because LPN has more options. One of the things I would LOVE to do is join a team such as Smile Makers (I believe it's called) not for profit group that goes into third world countries and gives people medical care they would never get elsewhere. That is a big motivating factor for me doing this. I know I need to get the experience once I'm trained then I'm hoping to join such a team and I've been trying to figure out wether OR tech or LPN would be of more help in those areas, plus of course which I would enjoy more.


I recently had my knee operated on (old and a runner, not good.haha) and that is what I observed as they took me in the OR.  A group of people that seemed to know each other, seemed to be enjoying themselves and liked their jobs.


Thanks for the input!