Everything Nurses >> Nursing Politics/Activism >> Should nurses be mandated to be bilingual?

Rate

Should nurses be mandated to be bilingual?

2,079 Views
40 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Picture_001_max50

19 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I think that nursing schools should offer foreign language as an elective. If the student wants to take the class so they can say on a resume they are Billingual then that's the student choice. I would take a Spanish class. The reason why is because, I know that I will run into a lot of non English speaking patients in my area. I live near Kansas City Missouri. So, thats why I hope to take a class or learn on a computer how to speak Spanish. Plus, I see all the time in the want ads when an employer is looking for health care workers they always say "Billingual a Plus"

Photo_user_blank_big

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I do not go to a foreign country and expect them to speak English. So why are we expected to speak Spanish? I paid for my entire education out of pocket, while nurses I worked with admitted to sneaking over the border to become American. Yes, they speak Spanish and call themselves Mexican-American because they came illegally over the border to become American? Fair? Biligual yes.

Injured_max50

238 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I do not think anyone was trying to be racist or think they are superior than those who do not speak spanish. I agree with georgianurse. Immigrants who want to become citizens of the United States should be mandated to speak our language. We are an english speaking nation. I have been to Mexico and not one person there spoke English. Should I have been upset..no because I was in Mexico and it is a spanish speaking country. If nurses want to learn spanish then more power to ya (and it does help on resumes because there is more education involved) but if you don't then that should be fine too. There are too many cultures in America to single on one particular group and learn that specific language. Learning spanish does not increase patient safety when the patient is from Vietnam or China. It doesn't make sense.

Photo_39_max50

348 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

Mandatory? No. Reccomended? yes.Nurses have more opportunities in which to advance themselves if they speak more than one language. However, hiring nurses JUST because they speak another language should not be the sole criteria for hire. Ability to speak more than one language needs to part of a PACKAGE.

We can't forget the other skills that a nurse needs to have to be effective, so if a nurse has language, technical, psychosocial and theory skills, there is every reason to consider him/her for a position in a chosen field.

teaamRN

Photo_user_blank_big

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

phunaries said:

This is becoming a serious problem. Not only is there a serious shortage for nurses in this country, Were hiring foreign nurses also, for there ability to speak a second language. Do you think that we should be mandated to speak a second language? Why or why not? Do you think this is a good or bad idea?

I don't think that it should be necessary because if they are coming to this country then they need to speak the language. Just like if I was going to a foreign country then I would learn enough of their language to be able to function properly. That's the way that I think it should be here.

Al_chamizo_max50

1016 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

teamrn said:

Mandatory? No. Reccomended? yes.Nurses have more opportunities in which to advance themselves if they speak more than one language. However, hiring nurses JUST because they speak another language should not be the sole criteria for hire. Ability to speak more than one language needs to part of a PACKAGE.

We can't forget the other skills that a nurse needs to have to be effective, so if a nurse has language, technical, psychosocial and theory skills, there is every reason to consider him/her for a position in a chosen field.

teaamRN

Here, here... I would say, strongly recommended. It would just launch nursing and patient care to another level, not just having the skills of our hands, but to actually reach into a culture and make a difference in your own words without the need of mediation.

1176_max50

32 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

Americo said:

Remember people that Medical attention should not be deny to anyone in any country of the world. United States of America has (and it will always has) many different ethnicity from different part of the world I think that in different part of the country Nurses should learn basics words in another language.
There are been cases where babies has die because of the parent lack of communication. That is why I think that in some part of the country Nurses should know basics words in another language.

You are so right! If were not being made to learn another language or we choose not to by our own will, then I do agree that we as nurses should learn basic medical tearms in another language depending on where we live and what that language might be.

240_max50

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

no, we shouldn't have to learn spanish. i was in europe twice and no one there would bend over to speak english. why should we. if you want to be here or live here learn english. why do certain people always want the majority to change for the few.

240_max50

2 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

al_chamizo said:


teamrn said:


Mandatory? No. Reccomended? yes.Nurses have more opportunities in which to advance themselves if they speak more than one language. However, hiring nurses JUST because they speak another language should not be the sole criteria for hire. Ability to speak more than one language needs to part of a PACKAGE.

We can't forget the other skills that a nurse needs to have to be effective, so if a nurse has language, technical, psychosocial and theory skills, there is every reason to consider him/her for a position in a chosen field.

teaamRN


Here, here... I would say, strongly recommended. It would just launch nursing and patient care to another level, not just having the skills of our hands, but to actually reach into a culture and make a difference in your own words without the need of mediation.


you must be spanish. its seems that some spanish nurses are in fever of americans speaking spanish. why? its easier for spanish people they don't have to speak or learn english, all one language, one happy family. no this is america we speak english learn the language of the country. if you want to speak spanish move to south america where they need spanish speaking nurses who are highly trained. i was in a mexican hospital and no one offer to speak english except when it to pesos and no one really cared.

033_max50

9 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 5 years ago

 

I do not believe we should be mandated if that is the case will it also be imperative that we learn all the languages....we have all nationalities......i feel that it should be the patients responsibility to get an interpreter they are here, you can't go to Germany and find a mandate to learn English....and you can't go to Mexico and find mandated laws that they learn English even in the medical field......