Everything Nurses >> Nursing Politics/Activism >> Prochoice Nurses

+2

Prochoice Nurses

361 Views
16 Replies Flag as inappropriate

-57 posts

back to top

Posted over 4 years ago

 

I about fell out of my chair when I heard John McCain say this during the presidential debate last night:

"Just again, the example of the eloquence of Sen. Obama. He's 'health for the mother.' You know, that's been stretched by the pro-abortion movement in America to mean almost anything. That's the extreme pro-abortion position, quote, 'health.'"
— Sen. John McCain, during presidential debate


Since when did women's health become extreme?


What's really extreme here is that John McCain doesn't understand that women's health matters.


What John McCain said last night, in front of millions of viewers, was belittling to women. He not only mocked Barack Obama for supporting women's health, he mocked women across the country. The debate last night was just the most vivid example of what we've known all along: John McCain is out of touch on women's health.


The simple fact is that we need a president who wants to protect and promote women's health, not ridicule it. If John McCain doesn't understand that, then he's not prepared to govern this country.


Remember, this is not the only example where John McCain doesn't get it when it comes to women's health.


Just a couple months back, McCain had the deer-in-the-headlights look, and couldn't answer whether he thought it was fair that insurance companies that cover Viagra should also cover birth control.


And, remember the time when McCain was asked whether he thought condoms helped stopped the spread of HIV? McCain's response, "You've stumped me."


And there's more. Let's count the ways that John McCain is out of touch on women's health and women's rights:



    • He's voted 125 times against women's health.

    • He wants to overturn Roe v. Wade.

    • He opposes funding to prevent unintended and teen pregnancies.

    • He opposes requiring health care plans to cover birth control.

    • He opposes equal pay legislation, saying it wouldn't do "anything to help the rights of women."

    • He's proposed a health care plan that will be worse for women.

Barack Obama, on the other hand, gets it. Obama talked about commonsense proposals to prevent unintended pregnancy. He talked about a woman, along with her family and her doctor, deciding what is best for her health care.


The simple fact is that Barack Obama is a passionate advocate for women's rights, and has a long and consistent record of standing up for women's health care. As president, he will improve access to quality health care for women, support and protect a woman's right to choose, support comprehensive sex education to keep our young people healthy and safe, and invest in prevention programs, including family planning services and breast cancer screenings.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: Women voting for John McCain is like chickens voting for Col. Sanders.


Cecile Richards, President


Planned Parenthood Action Fund

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

That was enjoyable dmazement!  Condoms help stop HIV....."you've got me stumped"!  Hillarious!!!!!!!  Did he really say that?  I believe it, but I'll go ahead and check to be sure.  McCain is so awkward.  Did anyone notice that last night.....especially after the debate was over and it was time to shake hands and say goodbye?  It's hard to watch him sometimes....I'm so embarassed for the poor guy.  I attached a picture below just in case anyone missed it.  It's called "McCain Does the Monster Mash Again"!  ROTFL.....LOL  ;-) 


I think the reason McCain and his supporters push the eloquence issue so much is they're jealous because McCain is far from it.  I also find it interesting that McCain tends to spin some of his campaign slogans during debates so they sound similar to Obama's.  Like the increase in computer technology for healthcare to reduce mistakes/cost.  This was during the second debate only moments after Obama proposed it (but more eloquently of course). 


I really hope that McCain supporters are not just voting for him because he's pro-life and that there's more depth to their decision-making. 


 



~ Melissa

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Too bad....the picture didn't show.  Here's the link


http://johnmccain.mixx.com/photos/2472431/mccain_does_the_monster_mash_during_debate


~ Melissa

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Mccain Does the Monster Mash During Debate

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Mine worked, hilarious.


Yes he said all those things. 

-1 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Wow, Do you guys judge the quality of your doctors by how eloquent and good looking they are? 


That is so superficial.

-1 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

I want you to think hard.  Would you be making fun of the way Obama walked it he had a significant medical history?  John McCain earned his walk.  Two broken legs, a broken arm, both arms pulled from their shoulder sockets during five years of torture.  If Obama had that kind of history, would you be making fun of his 'awkwardness'?

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

LOL  No kitty, not at all!  There's many, many things that I consider in individuals.  It was just very comical to see him last night and then come across a photo as well.  I was literally laughing for a good fifteen minutes!  So, I should thank him...because he just provided me with an opportunity to boost my health (they say laughing is good for you).


His level appearence and articulation have very little to do with my decision to not vote for him.  It's really about the issues.  Sorry if I upset you!  ;-)


 


~ Melissa

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

I'm really not poking fun at his injuries either.  I mean, come on, his tongue is hanging out!  I don't think that has anything to do with his war injuries.  It was a funny moment in time.  Laugh a little.  It's not that serious.


~ Melissa

-1 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

My brother was killed in Vietnam, I would have taken him back tongue hanging out, with a limp and in any condition.  So, I don't think I'll be laughing with you anytime soon.

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Well Kittyrn I lost my husband in Vietnam 2 weeks before his last tour.  Do I miss  him?  yes every single day, so you are not the only one who has suffered this type of loss.  I have many friends who are voting for Obama who are Vietnam vets.  Many suffer from PTSD, some are amputees, others have different physical disabilities.  All scarred from this war.


This is about prochoice.  You want to discuss the initial post, then post, but for crying out loud, does everyone have to nit pick at each other?

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Kitty,


I will gladly apologize to you, once again.  I am very sorry that this picture stuck a chord with you and you have mistaken my sentiment.  I am also very very deeply sorry you lost your brother.  My brother is a Marine at risk in Iraq as we speak, and I would never disrespect anyone's service in the military.  It was a funny picture....that's all.


Have a wonderful day!  ;-)


~ Melissa

-57 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

The reason I'm Prochoice is this.  Just about 27 years ago, a young girl, around 15 was life flighted to the trauma facility I was working as an OR nurse.  This young girl was hemorrhaging  vaginally, with a coat hanger hanging out of her.  When we began to undress her in the OR we found fresh, black nasty bruises all over her torso, legs, back.  Turns out her father beat her so badly, because she was pregnant and she did not have the money for an abortion, she decided to take matters into her own hands.  We lost her.  I was so angry over this, then and there I decided I would stand for women and their right to choose. 

Chris_hose__flowers_127_max50

505 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Wow dmazement, I can see how an experience like that would lead to your stance.


For me, the issue doesn't ever seem to be black and white.  It's always grey.  I can see validity in both perspectives, especially when poignant and plausible stories like this are shared.  I don't think it's appealing that some women are careless with their sexual practices and use abortion as a method of birth control.  BUT, that's not always the scenario.  Neither is it the case that all women who have abortions are selfish and don't want the "burden of a baby", nor are all women who have abortions of poor moral values.  Sometimes, women choose abortion because of rape or incest.  Sometimes, they choose abortion because the pregnancy is dangerous to their health.  To me, it doesn't really matter if there's only 1 woman per year needing an abortion for those latter two reasons, or even if it's just a possibility that someone might need this procedure.  Sometimes, it is necessary and makes sense.


So, I consider the collective result of both positions....... 


With a ban on abortion, those sometimes occurences are ignored, and the women in those predicaments (no matter how rare) are ignored.  Only one point of view, opinion, or option is acknowledged.


With pro-choice, there is consideration for those sometimes situations.  All women are given options to decide what they prefer.  They are free to still decide that abortion is not the right choice for them and they are free to elect to have an abortion if those sometimes scenarios occur. 


It becomes really controversial when the fetus/baby is discussed and that is so complex to address.   If those women who would have elected to abort are no longer given the choice, what would be the consequence? 


Adoption?.......sometimes


Abandonment?......sometimes


Hiding the pregnancy and thus jeopardizing their own health and the baby's health?........sometimes


Keeping the baby?...........sometimes


Keeping the baby and being a good parent?.....sometimes


Keeping the baby and being a neglectful parent (stemming from a variety of potential factors such as immaturity, crisis, poor environment, lack of support etc.)?................sometimes


Self-inflicted abortion?..........sometimes


Illegal unregulated abortion?.........sometimes


For me, the sometimes' and uncertainties are what lead me to believe that retaining individual choice is important in terms of the whole picture.  Me personally, I would not choose an elective abortion for myself.  I would adapt to the changes if I became pregnant unexpectedly.  But, I also have a supportive husband, family, and friends.  My husband and I have an education and the ability to make the money necessary to support a child, we're mature, responsible, and strong.  Some women do not live this scenario.  Some women NEED to have a choice. 


~ Melissa

Dock_max50

493 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

Wow Mellisa that post said everything I have always wanted to say but never quite knew how. You have a wonderful way with words! Maybe you should be a writer AND a nurse! Thank you.


"Softly. deftly, music shall caress you. Feel it, hear it, secretly possess you...."

Brian_max50

377 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted over 4 years ago

 

I am pro-choice and was really concerned to hear that Palin was against abortion in the case of rape or incest. I mean, how sad it would be for either case to have no choice but to carry a baby of such a violent act.


It conflicts with my religious beliefs, so I stuggle with saying this, but I just do not think that they should not have a choice.


I mean they did not have a choice in getting preg in these cases, did they??


I also hate to hear about all the children abused, neglected etc... If I had a choice to be in heaven or abused profoundly, I think I would choose heaven.


It is a very hard subject to discuss openly, because people judge those of us who are pro-choice as if we are monsters.


Of course, I think sex education should definetly also be in schools, which Palin also disagree's with, and this may be the only place some children may get it. I think you should have to sign a consent so if you do not want your child to participate, then okay. But, to not have this option available is irresponsiable, in my opinion. Its like Nancy Regan's idea of drug abuse, JUST SAY NO. Come on that obviously didn't work either...


Teaching abstinence is great, but that obviously doesn't always work either... Look at Palin's daughter... I do not judge her daughter, not at all, I just mean it didn't work in her own home. Sorry to drag Palin into this, but I was really shocked that she is that niave.


I WENT TO SINCLAIR COMMUNITY COLLEGE AND CAPITAL UNIVERSITY IN THE LATE 1980'S AND EARLY 1990'S. LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU FELLOW NURSING STUDENTS.