Everything Nurses >> Nursing Politics/Activism >> How do nurses feel about universal healthcare?
How do nurses feel about universal healthcare?
|
549 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago As Kittyrn said, "The FREE job market allows us to go where we want, and obtain jobs that allow us healthcare." Exactly - I purposely chose a career employer that provided full healthcare and drug coverage (free) during my employment and then for life, and for my wife too. There were other jobs I enjoyed more, and MANY others that paid more, but I made my choice partly on the benefits package, particularly health coverage. I'm glad I did - I'm now disabled, and my medical expenses are several thousand each week. Compare that to my good friend who chose the job he enjoyed most, with no benefits at all - last month he fell off his bicycle - even with the helmet, he had a head injury, and had to be admitted to the hospital - now he's $10,000 in debt to the hospital! I wish life were such that EVERYONE could have all the care they need for free - but that isn't as easy as it sounds to achieve! |
|
411 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Part of the issue with the expense of healthcare, is the malpractice. People who are litiginous can sue and win millions. This has foreced MD's to "cover" their butts, by ordering unecessary tests. I konow that may be just a small part of healthcare expenses, but trust me, it is definately a contributing factor. I had an uninsured pt yesterday who had been treated had the state hospital the prior week before. She was having abdominal pain, but all her tests ate the stste hosp came back negative. So, she came to the hospital whre I work. She was admitted in the obs unit and was recieving Morphine 6 mg IVP q4 hrs for her pain. Needless to say she was knocked out cold for the majority of my shift. The casemanager in the meantime began to work on getting her d/c'd. The pt's family came to visit at 5pm, and suddenly, my pt was awake. I informed her we were doing d/c planning. The GI doc was waiting on her records from the state hosp. The pt was annoyed and said, they never did that test where they put a tube down my throat. I explained that since other tests CT scan, labs etc were neg, then there would be no reason to do endoscopy.The pt was thne insisting that she have endoscopy. I was floored at this womans nerve. But, since there is always fear of litigation, she may bully the doc into getting her way. Disgusting! So, how is someone uninsured being treated unfairly I ask? She recieved treatment and a crapload of Morphine. Must be nice. Texas is the largest state of uninsured pts. It also caps malpractice suits to 250,000. I have never seen an uninsured pt turned away in the 2 years I've been here. Claire Kruszka |
|
207 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago If there were universal electronic medical records, she would have had her complete record and your Docs would have been able to evaluate if she was drug seeking or legit in her complaints. A lot of time and cost would have been saved. No risk of unnecessary procedures since her entire record would be there, best practices for her type of case would be followed and she would have been treated or referred to a psych program for eval. See=== a revolution in the way care is provided is needed now. RNprogressive |
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive says ...
I have no problem with having computer saved records for meds............but not for all the health record. I dont want big brother leaning on me if there is something in my past that could be 30 yrs ago, but if the occasion is forgotten through time............I dont agree with the whole idea. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
207 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago You must live a pretty wild life in Georgia for there to be something in your medical records the government could use against you. Are you in the witness protection program or something? STD's etc aren't that big a deal. The benefits outweigh the risks. RNprogressive |
|
893 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago lets see, DNA has linked all of the following as giving someone a higher chance of having any of the following... diabetes, colon cancer, breast cancer, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, gout....that might not be something people want known to potential employers..... My extensive military knowledge is not limited to just being in line at the commissary, I also have extensive military knowledge of the 'Class Six'. |
|
54 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago There are some in these posts who are naysayers and negative about everything that is suggested as possible fixes. Do we all agree that something needs to change? I'm glad for those of you who feel comfortable with what you have--good benefits, good jobs, pensions, etc, but not all of us have this. And it's not because we are slackers or poor decision makers. Nurses, as you all know, are not known for longevity in their positions. Many of us are single parents, taking care of elderly parents, you name it. Nurses have historically jumped from job to job when salary was better, hours were better, benefits were better some where else. Today I was speaking with a friend (a non-nurse) who was signing up for unemployment benefits. she said that she was told by one of the reps that if you are over 45 years of age, you are going to have a hard time finding something. She said there were probably 50 people in the offices with her and all appeared to be over that age except for a handful. She was advised not to include anything in your resume that would indicate age which I can't understand how you can do that. I myself have wondered a few times about age discrimination when I sent in over 20 resumes and heard back from 2 employers. My point is, I hope that all of you in good situations, remain in those good situations because it can be very scary when things change. and as you know, nothing is written in stone. |
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive says ...
Well, you have insulted me and in a very unproffesional way. I find it offensive, I have lost all respect for you as a nurse and as a person. I quoted you because in case somebody might have emailed you to warn you that you you might want to edit your post for offensive posting in what is suppose to be a nursing forum in an unprofessional posting. Tthis way your message wont go away cuz its right here. Have you ever known anybody who was under md care and being treated for symptoms those that resumbled MS.......................was unemployed for 6 monthes from his hospital position, worked in a md's office for triage............suddenly half a year flitted away, and then his symptoms that had the md's thinking he had MS, started improving. Later they abated totally. He couldnt get his old job back because his facility in the same department, that he would be a risk to the facility due to inability to physically perform the functions as a nurse. When he used his old supervisor as a reference, and he was a dang great nurse, he knew they wouldnt hire him when the person interviewing him asked "so are you feeling better these days? Have your symptoms improved? He took a job 70 miles away and moved due to that. On a standard nursing application, it asks if you are able to fulfill the physical requirements for this position. His Hippa protection was nonexistant. I told him he needed to sue for his hippa rights violation. He said since he didnt know exactly who told the person he wasnt fit for duty due to physical problems. He finally got a job south of Atlanta, had to move.............for 3 monthes he had to live in one of those suite hotels that have discounts if you rent for a week. For 5 years now, he has ran the Peachtree road race marathon. What if I was in a witness protection plan? Dont you think if that was a possibility, that would risk my life and my kids life? Are you any good at observing Hippa laws? I would be bothered with the type person you seem to be regarding hippa with that comment. What about the comments about 'being wild' and STD's? Where did you get your nursing license, RN veryUPROFESSIONAL? Walmart? I would say 'good luck'.........but Im not a hippocrite. I hope you dont have good luck. Would you have made that statement if I was Diabetic? Angie
We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
499 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago I want to say Kittyrn's comment about not throwing the baby out with the bathwater had me laughing. Never heard that before. LOL This is a very interesting subject. What I want to know is, as far as the free job market thing. My company, whom I love working for and have a great shift, no longer offers benefits aside from your 2 week vacation. Said the company could no longer afford to pay for healthcare. They tried giving a monthly bonus to "help" cover the cost of private insurance but they took that away too. So my family no longer has health insurance because my husband doesnt get it either. Am I capable of finding another job, sure, am I willing to lose my seniority and good schedule? I guess so. Can I find another job in this area? NO!!! and neither can my husband. We are grateful we even have jobs. Thankfuly none of us have any health issues at present. At least in my case none I am willing to have diagnosed without insurance in place. However, if anything happened to either one of us, we would be SCREWED! As an LPN, there is not shit for jobs around here, We are being replaced with ma's and med certified cnas in some LTC facilities. "Softly. deftly, music shall caress you. Feel it, hear it, secretly possess you...." |
|
54 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Nurse Jenny, I do hope your family stays very healthy. sorry to hear that you've lost benefits. Sorry to repeat myself but: I'm waiting for my COBRA benefits to kick in. Under the ARRA provision, I will pay 184.00 a month for individual coverage for the first 9 months of COBRA, then it goes to 533.00 a month for the remaining 9 months (if I need it that long). Right now, until the notification comes comfirming that I actually have the COBRA, I have put off my nephrology visits for the 2 procrit shots a month ($1800.00) and the iron infusions twice a month. I know my blood count is down again because I'm crawling into bed around 7:30 pm. My Hgb was 6 and went up to 8.2 with the shots. My nephrologist told me to start paperwork for disability benefits however, I can work when my blood count is up, and I want to work. The first thing I'm going to do when the COBRA OK arrives is make my lab appointment for blood work. Too scared now because they'll make me pay up front and that won't be pretty. So, please--hang on to your health. I was born with crappy kidneys, lost my benefited position in January and am steadily looking for work I am qualified to do. I have 18 months of COBRA before I really start freaking. |
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago NurseJenny..................I just walked in the room and there was a commercial for "affordable health insurance".................dang, I wish I had something to write with when I saw it. All I remember is it starts with a 'C', lol. They also said they had a dental option. and they dont count against pre-exhisting conditions. Crap, I'll watch for it...........the rates looked reasonable. If it comes back on, I'll email you the name/number. Oh, also I do have aflac that i purchase on my own. I get a cancer policy, if I get diagnosed with Cancer, even if its a gross mole that 'might' me skin cancer, Id get $2500.............I get a check for $50 when I get a mammogram.............my copay is $15 for a mammogram, so it pays for itself. For overnight stays in the hospital, $500/night for my hosp. policy..if Im in ICU, its $1500/night........short term disability, ......I had to pick how much I cant afford to not have, I can live on 60% of my salary. I pay about $35/month taken from checking acct on the 15th each month. This is off the subject, but for people who do agency work and might not have this type of benefit, it could help. Ive done agency work for a few monthes and love it, the money was fabuous, and I picked the days I want to work, and dont answer the phone If I dont want to work and know its them calling me and I cant get into trouble. I've found agency work pays more..............there are 2 hospitals that I love going to, and 1 Im not crazy about...dont hate them..........but would pull a shift for $36/hr for day shift. After you get to know the people who are the regular staff members, they can get attitude because they know I'm making more than they do even though I dont get benefits <I wouldnt want their benefits> Once you get to know a few of them, its not bad. I watch my contributions for my 401K <or whatever it is now, my ex401k>, Whatever this is I make sure to contribute 10% minimum because Im turning into a sea hag type nurse and dont want to have to keep doing this. When I finish my bsn, Im jumping right into grad school and I think I want to do nurse education or might want to get my practioners license. They say that if you put it off too long, you cant do that after 2010...............I gotta hustle. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
207 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Angie of Georgia, Geez lighten up it was a joke! I guess you don't live a wild life in Georgia. I didn't imply you had any sort of condition it was an example. I didn't imply employers know your medical records only your doctor. Also a horrible story about your friend with MS symptoms but if he was cleared of having MS and he is physically able to do the work then this would be in portable medical records as well. If he is cured then he doesn't have any diagnosis so he is capable of working and running as you state in your lengthy message. I never implied anyone was allowed to violate HIPPA laws only you could transport your medical records easily in a data stick or another device and hand them to any ER Doc etc if you needed care away from home or at a specialist. Of course the highest firewall etc would need to be on these to prevent hacking etc. Actually I have 3 degrees from excellent schools and they teach laughter is the best medicine, lighten up. It wasn't abusive especially compared to some of the things written here. RNprogressive |
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive.; If you have been to 3 different wonderful schools, if they taught you ethics and legalities in nursing, and passed you, you were robbed. Id get my money back. I have never taken in courses in laughter............its not in my ciriculum..
Do you think Hippa will protect you from the universal health czar? He's the big kahuna of health care. Someone we didnt elect, but appointed by an elected President has 32 CZars. The definition of a czar is emporer. Our Facist President has put czars to goven over all of our lives. When reporters try to find out who the czars report to...................none of the journalists have been able to get an answer. We have 32 czars................and skyrocketing taxes. Id call this taxes without representation. Yanno, I dont live a wild life. My husbands and mines date nite is splitting a subway sandwich and watch American Idol when its in season. Does anybody know who the czars will report to? And howmuch are they paid? We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
207 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Good job Angie you hit the Republican talking point of the day. 2-3 pages on Google all address the same issue from every conservative site and blog. Czars-- many presidents have used them, Bush certainly did. Admittedly our President is using more in this administration probably because he needs their expertise quickly to solve the problems left by Bush. Bush ran up the deficet, Bush started a war of choice, Bush allowed our infrastucture to founder etcetcetcetcetcetc. No one is talking about an exclusively government run health care system in America only the right wing talking heads are saying this to scare you. BOO!!! All of you do more reading away from Fox, Washington Times and Rush and O'Reilly the Entertainers. Czars report to the president and are defined in the dictionary as::An appointed official having special powers to regulate or supervise an activity The pay Czar is working probono by the way.
I still don't know what you are talking about my ethics and legalities. I got it his former employer shouldn't have said anything about his physical abilities if he said it was related to a specific condition. Your friend can sue. I agree in upholding HIPPA and consistently do this in my life.
RNprogressive |
|
1446 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Is it possible that we can stop the name calling and get back to discussing "How do nurses feel about universal healthcare?" I am against it for many reasons, the number one being that I do not want the government running something as important as my healthcare. Why? Because historically and in both republican and democratic administrations, anything the government controls ends up costing more and more money and the bureaucracy always finds ways to make it more complicated. But I am willing to listen to any arguement for and against and there have been some good ones here. Lets please get back to the discussion. One should study Philosophy, Archeology and History: Because
|
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Okie dokie, john..............I'll quit being mad over her tasteless 'JOKE'..................honestly, its a touchy subject, each and every comment referring to me as the partier type, mentioned STD's.............Im blonde and have fought to prove myself that I am every bit as qulaified as the next nurse who passed the nclex. I was normally in 'the cool group' in social circles, I perky, have fun, Im high on life, not drugs or booze...........but have never done anything to embarrass my family or children. I havent gone out for New Years Eve in 10 years. And yes, I reread her comments, and feel no change in my thoughts. Who wants universal medical records? I dont. They proved in the last couple of days they cant keep the federal buildings safe in Washington. As a test they checked to see how the federal people who were suppose to be guarding these federal places......were incompetant.........and one of the officers was caught putting a baby through an X ray machine. Nobody needs to be put in an xray machine. That kid can come out with cancer later in life. That officer got fired..........but sued the govt and got his job back. They showed this when they put a segment on about cyber attacks by possibly north korea to DOD, the white house, Wall Street, and the treasury. Do any of yall still want computerized medical records? Well, maybe the North Koreans would be better at running our country than nobama would................actually, I feel safer if they were running America. Woudnt it be interesting if the dude with the bad hair cut sent nobama to guantanimo...........and had him be roomies with the Weedins or whoever the dudes are who got a condo in Bermuda <they were arressted for being in the taliban or something>. Think about it.............Obama, Pelosi, Murtha, and Rob Emanueel as roomies at Guantanimo. Ok, Im going back to bed now. Sweet dreams to everyone. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
320 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago again i go back to my solution. let's use the current medicare sustem we now have and expand it. we already have tons of money invested in it. our case managers and other people already know how it works and the red tape is already set up. i t could be the cheapest fix by far. that way we can leave alone those of you who already have healthcare that they like and can afford . i don't mind paying and extra 1000 a year to cover all 45 or 47 million people who have no insurance. oh maybe 1000 isnt enough maybe it will be more who knows who cares just so they leave us alone. Tax the hell out of me but stay the hell away from my life. ha PS electronic med records are up and running in our hospital and yeah its great until somebody forgets to pay the electric bill or we get hacked by the North Koreans!! too bad nobody can look at the chart and really know whats going on with the patient ...by far the best report on the pt comes form the horses mouth and not the computer screen!! |
|
320 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago one more thing to MaggyC i hope you get your very much needed iron and procrit soon. you may already know this but i wanted to let you know that 2 companies who make your procrit are AMGEN and JOM pharmaceuticals each has a customer # . this line is avail for you when you need it to ask them about "compassionate use" meaning free or reduced payment for medications neccessary to promote life. 1800 2729376 is AMGEN and 18664895957 is for JOM good luck and happy rbc building |
|
320 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago when i said horses mouth i meant the Nurse!! |
|
893 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago I'm the first to admit electronic charting is cumbersome when you start and they need to find some better charting methods but saying the patient is always the best source of accurate info is not true. Pts seeking narcotics, those to ill to respond, the elderly who have mutiple docs who prescribe conflicting meds, those in accidents too young to give good info and before family arrives, etc. Truly they need to place adequate security on the systems to prevent hacking etc. But there is no going backwards to papercharting the risk of errors and medication errors is very great, there is plenty of research on that in the literature.
I PREDICT, electric charting will come into fashion. We will have some type of universal computer bank, where all of our information is stored. I further predict, that this system will fail. It will be hacked into, need to be rebooted in emergency situation (valuable information will be unavailble to large sections of the public), maybe due to power outage, computer viruses, lightening strikes, etc. The result will be THIS, we will be chipped at birth. Just like people chip their prized horse, or their pedigreed dog. Your information will be implanted, and stored on your person. They will declare that your information will be 'more secure' in this way...no hackers, and readily available. And for the record, I am not endorsing this. I am not a dog or a horse, I was born free. This will be the end of freedom. Why? We'll be tracked, just like your cell phone can be tracked. This will be the end of privacy, and just the begining of big brother. BTW, those that have known me for years. Also, know that I've been predicting this for over 20 years. My extensive military knowledge is not limited to just being in line at the commissary, I also have extensive military knowledge of the 'Class Six'. |
|
411 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive says ...
Well, the hospital we were trying to get records from is state run, so I'm not sure if they are doing electronic med records yet. the facility where I work has total computer charting. As par ususal a government run facility is behind the times. But, hey let them run our healthcare! My other concern as was Angie's, was with the advent of all this, there will be more information being given to the government regarding your medical status. This means if you have co-morbidities, they could deny treatments based on the fact that its to expensive. The government is already amassing too much power. Don't think I want to give them anymore. Claire Kruszka |
|
549 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago going back to medical records for a moment: From a legal standpoint, any mention of psych meds or treatment, or of having an STD, can jeopardize your application for certain jobs, particularly those requiring a clearance. |
|
893 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Even a childhood diagnosis of ADD or ADHD, can jeopardize government jobs requiring a security clearance. My extensive military knowledge is not limited to just being in line at the commissary, I also have extensive military knowledge of the 'Class Six'. |
|
320 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago one point about our electonic charting and this definitely relates to universal healthcare the gov will be in your business and it will be SO easy. that is if you make it out of the hospital in one piece. ha ..our biggest contributor to the new charting system was GE which is also in line to get millions of gov contracts for additional "Healthcare Spending" interesting they have their hands in both pies the universal healthcare option and the electronic charting . HMMMMM anyone see some alarming connections? also to address the lit that speaks to less errors with electronic charting our hospital has more quality variances now than we ever did with paper charting. not sure why maybe its a learning curve. |
|
1446 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago kellyj says ...
MMMMMM Kellyj, it is very interesting that GE has their hands in both. I was watching a program on TV about electronic medical records and it talked about how great the possibilities are for having a persons complete medical record from birth on computerized so any physician they go to anywhere in the country will know all about them. Any physicain would include employee physicians, insurance company physicians and of course government physicians. Does anybody see the horrible consequences that can occur with this? Being turned down for a job, denying all types of insurance and just the knowledge that the government might deny you "Universal Health Care", because of your medical hiostory. "Big Brother" is watching and wants to know even more. One should study Philosophy, Archeology and History: Because
|
|
54 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Thank you Kellyj! I will check it out. |
|
207 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago Are you all so woefully uninformed of the healthcare proposal's on the table or just making things up. A major tenant of this new healthcare reform is that no one can be denied insurance for any reason. No one for any reason. That means if there is something in your record that any physician can see you will still be insured. Now you may not get any job you want and there maybe a darn good reason for that. I have two grown children with forms of ADD they can't be in the military nor should they be because they can't do the job due to their disability. Both their father and I are veterans and they want to serve but cannot. They serve their country other ways with volunteerism etc. Really this forum should be titled Right wing nurses for the same old thing. Big brother bothers you now? It didn't bother you when the Patriot act was passed, it didn't bother you when your voting rights disappear, it doesn't bother you when science is denied etc. The last 8 years were progressively terrifying as to the erosion of our civil liberties. We may finally be coming out of the black hole and you all cannot or will not see it. I rant because I care about America.
RNprogressive |
|
1446 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive, I understand that one of the proposals is that no one can be denied insurance for any reason. If this is passed, and i seriously doubt that it will be, can you tell me the cost to insure everyone? obama can not. when he was asked he said he didn't know. Either it is so expensive they do not want to tell us, or they are so stupid they really do not know. I do not like obama, but I can not believe that the president of the United States is stupid. so my thought is it is very expensive. I really have never seen any cost published yet. If you know RNprogressive, I would be interested to know. Although I am concerned with government getting deeper into our lives, my biggest concern is the cost to taxpayers. I also rant because I care about America. One should study Philosophy, Archeology and History: Because
|
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago In regards to the patriot act...............wrong. I am so glad that having the Patriot Act working when It was working, probably saved thousands of lives in LA. The dude that was the mastermind over the terrorist plot to kill the people in LA was water boarded, lol. Was that Cheneys baby? LOL. Whoever wants to tap my phone, go right ahead, Im boring so get comfy, so go right ahead. I will fight this idea on electronic charts, not because the Omamanites might take away my healthcare.............I dont want it because it can keep me from getting a job. Im not someone who cant work, I can work so I choose to do so as I have since I was 16. The dems who have fought against phone taps are still in power, so you wont have worries until the next election. If only wire taps were in effect prior to 911, over 300 needless deaths could be stopped. Before anybody want to go off on Bush..........remember Clinton had Bin Laden and let him go. Clintons staff member stuck documents that were classified down his pants because he was going to shred them............he got them in the Natl Archives. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
1328 posts back to top |
| Posted 4 months ago RNprogressive says ...
We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |

