Everything Nurses >> Venting Zone >> Poll: Nurse Jackie
Poll: Nurse Jackie
Poll: How do you view Nurse Jackie?
|
11 posts back to top |
Posted about 4 years ago Last night I viewed the new Showtime "Nurse Jackie" with Edie Falco. This show is at best appalling. It is an insult to all nurses but even more so to those who may have the disease of addiction. In a world where medical professionals have little addiction education, this show is dangerous!!! The content demeaning to all nurses. As professionals please make your voice heard about this program. It can be viewed for free on Itunes. To have our profession portrayed in this manner is unacceptable!! |
|
5 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I will abstain from voting on the series and have very serious concerns regarding the show, which I expressed to Showtime the third week of April. I understand that most nurses and the media have no clue what actually happens to nurses like Jackie' in real life. So I offered Showtime producers and Edie Falco a complimentary copy of "Unbecoming a Nurse: Bypassing the Hidden Chemical Dependency Trap" so they could be sensitive to this complex issue. I hoped they could decrease any seductive allure to nurses, especially students, new graduates and those in recovery, who might contemplate mimicking Jackie's behavior. I was informed the offer was passed on, but have heard nothing since. Research demonstrates that the brains of addicts, even in long-term recovery, light up with activity while watching graphic displays of drug use and the non-addict brain does not. I DO believe, like Rosie Smentkowski, that there is a risk to nurses in recovery as well as the most vulnerable - those who have been exposed to mood altering substances through valid prescription or recreational experimentation. As Vicodin was the most frequently prescribed medication during 2008, thousands of nurses fall into either or both of these susceptible groups The link created by co-producer Liz Brixius' on-line comment, and I quote, "I would rather have this woman take care of me, my children, my loved ones when high than really any other nurse in the world," directly links the high nurse as the preferred nurse. This is alarming. This dangerous and provocative combination of terms invites not only loss of job and license, but professional and criminal prosecution as well as loss of health and possible death. When we already have someone entering an emergency room every six minutes related to a drug overdose and one death per hour from an overdose, the risk to nurses and the public seems enormous. Paula Davies Scimeca, RN, MS
|
|
537 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago
I watched Nurse Jackie and I was appalled @ how they portrayed nursing. Where do they get these nurses that can go out and spend time @ a sit down lunch and enjoy themselves and why is it that every RN must be screwing around with some doctor or intern or what ever. I just hop that the new show Hawthorne is more relastic that nurse Jackie. I will not be watching Jackie. Why did they insist that she must be a pill popper. The only part that I can say that I enjoyed was when she was telling the one resident off because he didn't order tests she thought should have been ordered (why didn't she become an advocate for that patient and push the issue) but then they had to ruin it when they ha him put his hand on her boob. Nurse Jackie is not for me. UNACCEPTABLE!!!! Our service to others is the rent we pay while here on earth!! |
|
1306 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I havent seen the show.......maybe I shouldnt make a comment, but here goes anyhow. I've been hooked on another show on showtime for a coupld of years "the Tudors" and for that reason I've seen seen the commercials and what I remember was Edie Falco using a razor to cut up what I think was a lortab and then sniff it like cocaine........... I agree with both comments north of this one if it protrays nurses using drugs like that. My Mother in law <high school graduate> and 30 yr retirement as from St St Joeseph hospital in Atlanta.....as a pharmacy assistant............she also swears to this day that St Joes physicians prescribe cocaine. I quit arguing a long time ago. Sometimes its best to bite my tongue and tell my mother in law that I love her, lol.........yall know how those with a little bit of knowledge is dangerous? THAT IS MY MOTHER IN LAW. She has told everybody for years that nurses steal drugs, lol..........and asked me if I ever tattled on somebody who probably stole narcotics. Well, I have tattled, but did it to cover my ass and hoped I prevented a danger to our facility. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
5 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago Dear Angienwgeorgia, Reporting a colleague for suspicious behavior is not tattlin. It is a mandate to all nurses stated in the American Nurses' Association (ANA) code of ethics. "As an advocate for the patient, the nurse must be alert to and take appropriate action regarding any instances of incompetent, unethical, illegal, or impaired practice by any member of the health care team. Nurses must be vigilant to protect the patient, the public and the profession from potential harm when a colleague's practice, in any setting, appears to be impaired." This code goes on to describe an additional requirement of all nurses towards colleagues suspected of questionable or impaired practice : "The nurse extends compassion and caring to colleagues who are in recovery from illness or when illness interferes with job performance." In view of nurse comments on other blogs, many nurses do not uphold this ethic. Clearly at the end of the first episode Nurse Jackie has hung a wrong IV on a patient and admits almost killing the patient. Within the same half hour she has stolen money, absconded with a body part, forged a patient's signature, lied directly to multiple family members and used stolen, controlled substances which she has adulterated for greater effect. All the above must be profiled very vigilantly, vigorously and publicly by nursing professionals as criminal activities which in real life translate to loss of job, loss of license, public humiliation, prosecution and sometimes jail and death. Paula Davies Scimeca, RN, MS |
|
9 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago Circumstances had me in the home of a friend who wanted to watch Nurse Jackie. That is one mistake I will not be repeating any time soon. I was disgusted. And Paula, you left out one other despicable action - Jackie's indiscretion in the pharmacy. |
|
Account Removed -57 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I agree with all of you. I'm usually the first one to nay say, but this time I stepped back until others posted before adding my opinion. I found Nurse Jackie to be absolutely appalling and wouldn't watch it, even if I subscribed to ShowTime. |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago To all of you brave nurses sharing your feelings here, Thank you !!! And please have your friends write in too!!!! We need your voices. You more than anyone count!!!! Rosemary |
|
Account Removed 0 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I do not have Showtime, but after reading the other post about this new "nurse" show- the word "nurse" is used loosely. I am also agast at the insinuation that drug use among nurses or rather hospital based nurses is common. I am assuming based on an earlier post that "Nurse Jackie" has access to the pharmacy. I know from my experience, that is not possible. What ashame that we as a culture make drug abuse among healthcare professionals a common and almost expected action! |
|
537 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago
I am gald to see that so far no one has found this show entertaining. I know that TV is make believe but when we are protraying a profession that needs to be respected I think the producers need to take in to consideration the thoughts that the public may have. I know there are nurses that do drugs and seal from patients. It's possible to pocket pain meds from a patient that is unable to confirm meds were given. This is where nurses need to stand up and be accountable and be the patient advocate. I suppose the producers don't think the truth about nursing is all that interesting. If this is the case maybe they need to look @ the ratings for Discovery Heath and see how many people watch Trauma in the ER and these shows. These shows can be informative and how the interest of the main stream public. How about giving the average American credit for having a brain and not wanting to watch mindless shows. There are some bad nurses out there but does the main character have to be a pill popping, sarcastic, sex maniac~~ what about a making her a some one that young girls canlook up to. Again I am hoping that Hawthorne will take the high road. ~~~~ Cheryl Our service to others is the rent we pay while here on earth!! |
|
628 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I'll have to reserve judgement until I have actually seen the show. But I will be watching it soon. |
|
453 posts back to top |
| Posted about 4 years ago I posted a topic on this a week ago. I caught the show early online. Joost was allowing a "free" preview.I was appaled at how this nurse was depicted. I also pointed out how a pharmacist can't just give narcotics to a nurse like that. Again, Hollywood is clueless. Claire Kruszka |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago Voice of descent, I guess. I love the show. I love Edie Falco. It's a TV show, maybe I'm naive, but it's not an invitation to abuse drugs or behave promiscuously on the job. As a grown woman I know right from wrong and I think that implying that the behavior would be mimicked by nurses is the same as blaming Marilyn Manson for every teen suicide in the 90s. The majority of Showtime's series center around the glorification of very dark subjects. Dexter is about serial killer, Weeds is about a suburban mom who is a drug dealer by trade, US of Tara makes light of Disassociative Disorder. I agree that Nurse Jackie isn't for everyone. It's a 30 minute television program that probably appeals to very specific demographic. I have a dark sense of humor, and like most dramas, Nurse Jackie is borderline absurd. Any nurse that chooses to use on the job is going to do it without the influence of a TV show and I think that those who find it so incredibly offensive are missing the tone of the show. |
|
24 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago I read all of the posts last month and I am glad to see that recently a few people have stated that they like they show. It's a TV show! Truthfully, as a nurse I do not place myself on some pedastal to look down on others from, I am just as prone to diseases such as addiction, and marital infidelaties as the next guy...nurses are human beings too. I am extremly proud of the job that we do as nurses, but a show that was realistic is just not what I want to watch. And yes, I like trauma in the ER, but we do not all work in the ER. And the discovery health show doesn't show all the people who come into the ER needing refills on their scripts, have a fever , or are drug seeking...very real but not very exciting. Would you watch documentary at a nursing home? I don't think so but the nurses who work at nursing homes have incredably important jobs. If people ask you if Nurse Jackie is what it's really like, kindly let them know that you've never caught your co-worker snorting pain meds and that real nurses hardly get a lunch break, let alone have time to have sex in the pharmacy. :-) |
|
5 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago While I am delighted that rrybak has never witnessed a nurse colleague snorting meds, there are a growing number of nurses who know a colleague who diverted medications or forged prescriptions for controlled substances. Since the first episode aired, there have been dozens of nurses arrested for such incidents ranging in age from 22 to 71. The face of addiction even within our own profession is changing and the instances which make sensational headlines are just the tip of this dilemma in our profession. The issue has been recognized by every State Board of Nursing and the ANA for decades. I do hope that as we progress in our professional practice that we individually and collectively do more than pay lip service to The ANA Code of Ethic 3.6 which directs us to "extend compassion and caring to colleagues who are in recovery from illness or when illness interferes with job performance." If ten to twenty percent of our patients were falling out of bed incurring injury sufficient to warrant them unable to work at their profession for at least three months, or possibly never again, I know as a profession we would have a much more concerned and proactive response. Paula Davies Scimeca, RN, MS |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago "Since the first episode aired, there have been dozens of nurses arrested for such incidents ranging in age from 22 to 71." Just curious, where can I find the statistics to support your statement that drug related arrests amoung nurses have increased since the show aired? I'm sure that there have been arrests, I don't dispute that it's a big problem, only that it's reached pandemic proportions because of a 30 minute cable TV show. I'm quite confident that these arrests would have taken place with or without the show. For what it's worth, I've seen several nurses walk off the job when confronted with a drug screen. They find jobs in other hospitals. No evidence of drug use, no arrest, no blemish on their license. I'm sure they've been doing it for years. Maybe Nurse Jackie will bring this problem into the light and raise awareness about drug addiction among nurses. I'm not some huge advocate for the show, I just find it entertaining. |
|
5 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago I never stated that there has been an increase since the show aired, only that dozens of nurses have been arrested SINCE the show aired. I never assume a nurse has been "using for years" regardless of whether they walked off the job untested or tested positive. From over six years' experience working exclusively with chemically dependent nurses, I know that many nurses who surrendered their license to practice nursing due to a substance use disorder did not have a long-term history of inappropriate use or drug diversion. Some were tea-totalers, not even social users of any substance, including alcohol, who got into difficulty after a legitimate prescription of opiates or other mood-altering substance for a medical reason. It was not unusual for their misuse to be of less than 8 weeks duration. Every state has different legislation regarding how suspicion of diversion in nurses is handled and I cwill not comment on an individual case I know nothing about. But I stand firm in my conviction that the Nurse Jackie show depicts very graphically in a casual, almost flippant manner, the adulteration of an oral medication which is then inhaled in an isolated location without ever cautioning viewers that the inhalation of these close cousins to heroin can be, and often are, fatal. I have provided commentary on this subject (and will do so again tonight) on The Prescription Addiction Radio Show which can be heard live from 9-10pm each Sunday at www.860WGUL.com or on archive at www.prescriptionaddictionradio.com Paula, Davies Scimeca, RN, MS |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago Again, I personally believe that a nurse who is going to abuse prescriptions will not be influenced either way by a television show. Every nurse is educated about pain medications and fully understands the addictive properties of opiates. IF a nurse is using, or planning to use I fail to see how slapping a warning label on the show is going to infulence such a profound, deeply rooted problem. It's almost insulting to think that it would. |
|
5 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago Nurse Jackie is being viewed by more than nurses of long-tenure. As the most recent study of 12th graders notes there is an incidence of over 10% of them who have already used prescription medications for mood-altering effect. Therefore, the risk to me is very clear: a significant portion of youth that progress to nursing, pharmacy and medical school, and the general population, should at the very least be given fair warning regarding possible fatality from adulteration of prescription meds and subsequent snorting. As a nurse who takes the ANA code of ethics 3.5 and 3.6 extremely seriously - that being to protect the public and extend compassion and caring to colleagues who are in recovery from illness - I respectfully disagree with your view. Paula Davies Scimeca, RN, MS |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago I think it's great this topic is still getting "hits." Paula, keep up the good work! You know I'm in your corner!! Lucky13, after working with nurses in recovery, I can tell you most of them are highly educated, highly skilled nurses with little or no knowledge of addiction. I am amazed. Nurses do not get significant addiction education in training. (that is true, nor do MD's) However, if a nurse was diagnosed with any other illness: breast cancer, Crohn's Disease etc they would be EXPERT on that illness. This does not hold true for addiction. It could be denial, as trite as that sounds. The other issue for active addicts and persons in recovery, the show is a trigger. Do you think if the show portrayed teachers instead of nurses there would be more of an uproar? (the teachers union would crush it) My suggestion was, and remains, if the show is so entertaining, (and ratings $$$ rule) at the very least a PSA should be done at the beginning and/or the end of the show. Whatever your view, keep talking, keep asking questions, investigate, and keep your mind open. Public safety depends on it!!! |
|
11 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago I have not worked with nurses in recovery, I am not even a nurse myself yet. I have worked in healthcare for a few years and I've seen a lot of nurses come and go. I understand how the show could be a trigger, but so would any show that features a person snorting pain meds. The tone of the show is dark, as stated earlier in the thread it's not for everyone. I figure I'm now coming across as a huge defender of all things Nurse Jackie which is not the case. I simply don't agree that the show is responsible for a person's poor choices. I imagine someone will now say that it's a disease, not a choice....and again I'll have to disagree. |
|
9 posts back to top |
| Posted almost 4 years ago I like the show Nurse Jackie! It's just a tv show! relax, if some nurse had it in mind to do all that stuff it didn't start because of tv. If they can't separate reality and law from tv....... Oh, wait........... haven't I heard some people talking about some of the day time soap actors like they were REAL ??? And what about some of those people that try out for dancing with the stars or singing with ??? Maybe THOSE people shouldn't be allowed to watch anything but National Geographic. |
