Everything Nurses >> Nursing Politics/Activism >> Poll: would you go out on strike
Poll: would you go out on strike
Poll: Would you ever go out on strike
|
100 posts back to top |
Posted over 3 years ago My last paper that I did when I was in school was on this subject. I made no bones about how I felt because personally I think we deserve better thant what we get. For myself I would have absolutely no problem walking out on strike because management would then be left holding the bag for whatever happens. Although most public opinion polls hold nursing in very high regard, its a safe bet that the general public has no idea of what it is that we do on a daily basis and if they did my guess is that they would be shocked to find out the deplorable working conditions most of us put up with. So for me, I'd be ready to walk at a moments notice. Sure Id fell bad about the patients but at some point we need to hammer home to management that we're not going to take it anymore. Lets hear what every one else has to say.................... |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago You'll catch hell on this topic. A lot of it by people who consider anybody who doesn't think like them a "liberal". |
|
100 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Brownie I was going to vote for you but I new you'd be one of the first to respond............................LOL |
|
2506 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago mrbrownrn49 says ...
You may catch hell on this topic, but its 28 days after this post now and I fished this forum from the bottom of its catagory list so maybe not. I buy some liberal views, vote for some democrats usually in local positions, mostly Repulicans in federal positions, but am a Libratarian Party supporter by a large margin all for good reasons I've reserched. I don't vote on feelings, only hard facts, and some of the mundane speaches I view on C-Span (I like to know what they are doing) which I don't think many people with opinions know is on TV (they often just have feelings). We are a rather small party so chances of ever getting a real hammer into a position were he or she could make a difference is small, yet just like being a Michigan fan (Go Blue) I hold on to what I believe in unless a position and/or team comes down the road I buy. Have not found anything yet. This being said, both the Dems. and the GOP in recient times are which is the 'lesser of two evils' choices. Much ego floating around the political arena. Getting back to the premise of the post, I would stike only in an extreme condition. So I would do it. It is and should be ones right. I would not want anyone to die over it though. Sleep tight, don't let the bed bugs bite.
High hopes & God speed - Tim, R.N. |
|
100 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago After talking to a union here in Pa the nurses MUST give 10 days notice of a pending strike before they can walk out, so management would have plenty of time to move the patients before we left the building. So there now the patients will be covered and it will be impossible to put the nurses on the spot for poor patient outcomes........................... |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Move patients out? Only if travel nurse companies and local agencies couldn't supply enough nurses. And management would never get off their duffs to help cover. And you can always "wildcat" without a union. Decide on who calls in and leaves the place short staffed until both sides can agree. Of course you just have to deny any new admissions without a discharge for each new admit due to "staffing problems". You get your sick pay wildcatting. |
|
493 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago My question is.......say you do go on strike. (I think I would if I felt it was the only way to get the point across) Then the company fires you, or puts a bad mark on your record or you get sued, or any other thing that can happen.......for patient abandonment? "Softly. deftly, music shall caress you. Feel it, hear it, secretly possess you...." |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago If one goes out on strike - everybody goes on strike or you're a scab. If one gets to go back - everybody gets to go back - no exceptions. Either that or the strike continues. Plus with a union you don't get fired for petty reasons. If you get called on the carpet a union steward is allowed to be with you. Get fired and the union handles it. If it is deemed unfair or arbitrary and you get your job back you also get any pay you missed while absent and all your seniority back. Union NOW! |
|
100 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago This has nothing to do with the patient. Please do not add the patient into the mix as it confuses people. This is about the nurses plain and simple. More money, better ratio's, a pension, a lunch 1/2hour, (2) 15 min breaks, simple things that everyone else gets but somehow nurses seem exempt. Please stop thinking in terms of the patient FOR EVERYTHING you count too, wether you believe it or not. And if you fear your job security that much just let em try to come up with enough nurses to cover all three shifts for the next few weeks. Things can get militant in one heck of a hurry. REMEMBER THIS ISNT ABOUT THE PATIENT ITS ABOUT YOU...........................UNION NOW |
|
Account Removed -33 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago You could be fired, but it's only patient abandonment if you leave without reporting off to another RN. I've seen both sides - I was a Union Vice President for six years - but I've also been in management, and I saw a hospital strike where the strikers trashed a Mobile NICU ambulance (nice... in Newark, NJ - it figures). I've worked in a facility where the aides are unionized, and some of them get away with refusing to do their jobs properly. Management is afraid of the grievance process. I've seen facilities where management abuses the workers. I have also seen non-unionized facilities where management treats the workers like family (these are usually small facilities). So, sure, unions can be a great help to employees, but if run by the wrong people they are just another type of management, out for their own agenda, ignoring the needs of the workers. And Mr. B (sigh), of course it works both ways - there are some here who, if you don't think like they do, you are branded a "right-winger." Me, just a Libertarian who votes his conscience. |
|
509 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago we have open shop at my work. our dues are 1000 /year EGAD!! add that up people millions and millions $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ my point is this unions are giving their cash to lobby politicians and NOT the ones that are for your rights as a taxpayer! they are going for their own agendas maybe it works for yu but i find it a poor way to do business. i belong to the union but i fight my own battles i don't rely on someone stumping for someone else to have my best interest at heart ..if you think the union represents the worker you are WRONG they represent themselves the union and its dues pay for their agenda not yours! read your employee handbook write everthing down and keep accurate notes of what you percieve as some unjust situation ...the best protection from an employers agenda is your own knowledge of your rights as an employee. |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago So hospitals are rushing to advocate for safe staffing ratios? Limits on hours-per-day you can be forced to work? Mandatory overtime? Firing because some moron in administration has heard something bad about you? Or laying off staff to save money while doing nothing to limit admissions? It's like health insurance reform. Leave it to the insurance companies and it will never happen. It hasn't yet and never will. Same with the issues I am talking about. I have 30 years in this gig. I have a fair idea of what hospitals will and will not do. Union now. You can file a grievance with the union over worker performance. Union membership does not give one an ironclad job guarantee. It just takes some doing. And Cap'n - sigh loudly. The calls of "liberal" here are far louder accusations than the other way. I vote the man or woman or the issue, not the party. But as I age I notice clearly that progressive thinkers get tagged "liberal" while Fox News-types make it sound equal to a curse word. And I don't care what they call me as long as they call me for dinner. I was just stating the obvious to the OP. |
|
1306 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago We dont have nursing unions in GA. I use to fuss quietly about it but now Im glad we dont. Look what unions did to GM, Ford, Chrysler........I know different career types. I oppose unions and resent Obama trying to do that ballat that wouldnt be secret. Everybody in GA as nurses would say "bite me USA Govt'. The people who want ballots are edging up to government bailout in the future. Hell no I wouldnt strike. I have a bunch of friends who have been nurses for much longer than me and cant get a jobs. These nurses are wonderful nurses too.............. We only have one heart, take care of it! Angie |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago So if, against your wishes, a union came in and negotiated better hours, safe staffing ratios and better pay, Angie would refuse all those amenities? You would stick with high patient loads and lower pay since you object to unions. Right? |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago After talking to a union here in Pa the nurses MUST give 10 days notice of a pending strike before they can walk out, so management would have plenty of time to move the patients before we left the building. So there now the patients will be covered and it will be impossible to put the nurses on the spot for poor patient outcomes........................... I work at a union hospital in PA. A year ago, we gave 10 days notice of pending strike. It went to the last hour. I was told that our union reps/nurse reps were going to the meeting with santa hats on. Because they said everytime our contracts are up, the hospital always says "Hey, who do you think we are Santa Claus?". It's the other way around. |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Here's the start of a fight I'm sure. But please note that women never lead anything that takes a fight and guts at the same time. No auto union, no coal miners union, no teamsters are lead by a female. Unions came about for a reason. Union leadership has gone astray more than once. But I'll promise you if it were not for unions the US would not have an auto industry or railroads or coal. Nursing, as a predominantly female occupation, is ripe for abuse and boy do we get it. Say we don't and I'll know you're a pollyanna. |
|
493 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago MR Brown...........I agree that we, as nurses, dont get the best treatment. I do not however agree with the copmment about any thing run by females has no fight or guts.... You yourself stated that nursing is predominantly a female proffession right?..... And does nursing not take guts and fight....Every day? "Softly. deftly, music shall caress you. Feel it, hear it, secretly possess you...." |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago You betcha - for our patients. But why does it take state laws to make mandatory overtime illegal or safe staffing acuities a reality? Because when push turns to shove the women don't have the guts to take a stand with each individual hospital. To wildcat strike does not take a union. Neither does a sick-out. When have you seen either led by nurses? |
|
Account Removed -33 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago When I was a union VP in a mostly female work environment, it was very hard to get the workers interested - most were married and relied on the husband's pay and benefits - they didn't want to "make waves" by joining the union. BUT, they were not nurses, and this was many years ago. Still, I think the observation may still apply to some extent. |
|
100 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago So Kittyn Im curious what exactly transpired during the negotiation? Did you get better wages/benefits etc or did you wind up losing ground? Really would like to know what transpired. If you are at the hosp in Philly Crozier ? I know that you have a great pay and benefit package that we up in the other corner of the state dont enjoy. Please enlighten us... Thanks rondo |
|
628 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Nursejenny1310 says ...
Gotta love this management tactic to prevent strikes. If you're gonna tell a lie, tell a big one. You can only be dinged for abandonment once you have accepted report on a patient. If your union goes on strike, and you don't show up for your shift, it's not abandonment because you never took report in the first place. If your relief doesn't show up, administration can only force you to stay for so long; up to 16 hours total, then they MUST find someone to relieve you. Management knows when a strike is coming, and plans to have strike nurses on hand. There's no issue with patient care. And I would not advise Mrbrown's suggestion for a "wildcat" strike. It's bad advice (sorry Mrbrown, but it is) for this reason: nurses are "at will" employees. This means we can quit at the drop of a hat, and get fired at the drop of a hat, and they don't have to explain cause. Do a "wildcat" strike and you WILL get a termination on your employment record. However, you do not have to go to one of the big unions like CNA/NNOC or SEIU if you want to organize. You can do it on your own, and set up your own shop. Once you organize and hold a vote on whether or not to become a union, then you can collectively bargain with administration and go on strike, and they can't do anything to you. |
|
479 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Oh believe me I know a wildcat is bad. But to strike requires a union or a wildcat. The wildcat requires the hospital to simply let everybody return with no retribution, signed as a labor agreement/contract and negotiated by lawyers, or nobody comes back. THAT is the catch point with women and their innate sense of guilt. Dr. Phil has made a fortune on it. So have the hospitals. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Well, we certainly didn't lose ground. I know that there are disgruntled nurses that said we could have gotten better. However, having worked at several places in the south....We get 2 raises a year, performance based (average 3%) and cost of living (last year was 3% this year 1%). In all my years working as a nurse, I've rarely had a year that saw 2 raises. Additionally, we have longevity bonuses that vary according to hospital profit. I'm told this years was the lowest, because of the economy (.5% of annual gross). We have family sick days (if you don't use the family sick days they pay you for them at the end of the hospital fiscal year), a sick bank and PTO (PTO based on actual hours worked). We have decent health, and dental benefits. We have the usual health care savings accounts, and childcare accounts. Additionally, we contribute a mandatory 5% to retirement, and a 5% match from the hospital. The hospital has some kind of flexible health savings account that they put money in based on the type of healthcare benefits that you choose (up to a maximium of $2000 THE HOSPITAL PUTS IN NOT EMPLOYEE). If you don't use it after 10 years your fully vested and can keep up to a maximum of $20,000 to take with you as a healthcare spending account. Additionally, if we get accused of anything, or even called in to be quizzed on something that happened weeks ago, we have the right to have a union rep present. I've not used it, but my co-workers have. If we have a low census, there is a protocol in place as to who to offer it to (not willy nilly like it was in the south, with everyone fighting for favoritism to get sent home). We get seniority based on hours worked. The list is updated quarterly, and there are people that have been there 20 years, that are at the top. We can file complaints about low staffing per union protocol. Not philly, think Harrisburg area! |
|
4 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I,m in a situation in OH at a small facility. Our facility was bought by a corporation 2 years ago and the administrator is a real piece of work. She frequently downgrades employees, and some of our STNA,s have worked in this facility for 10-20years. It's a family atmosphere or at least it was before SHE arrived. She cut staff to begin with making the stress level 10 x more than it was. She makes the employees feel as if they can't say anything to her for fear of retribution. She tells the nursing staff we are a dime a dozen and that she could replace us at the drop of a hat. The bottom line has become $$ and in the area of the world I'm from that is not what makes the world go around. Also she has cut our raise from 3% yearly to 1.5% depending on state surveys and performance. My question is to anyone who has knowledge in this area, do we have reason to strike? There are many different grievances that I haven't listed but it's late and I just worked a double. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Small facility, and I'm hearing that your not union, not only will a strike not work, it will get you fired. If you don't have a union standing behind you, the best advice I can give is find a better job. |
|
628 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago sarahlint says ...
Kitty's right; if you are not union you cannot go on strike. If your facility has a grievance policy you could try that but odds are you are better off either quitting or organizing a union. Unionizing can be a difficult and stressful proposal; the corporation will do everything it can to break a union. Try contacting NNOC if you're an RN, or SEIU if you're an LPN or CNA. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago In our area SEIU covers RN's (I'm SEIU) and The Teamsters covers LPN's and CNA's. |
|
44 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I most certainly would go out on strike. You are only as valued as the value you put on yourself. |
|
2506 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago sarahlint says ...
|
|
Account Removed -5 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Sarahlint, Everybody should walk out en masse. The company will get the message. Then everybody agree to not return to work unless everybody gets hired back. New sign in - same old jerk here. Brown |

