Everything Nurses >> Nursing Politics/Activism >> Mandatory Flu Vaccine
Mandatory Flu Vaccine
|
10 posts back to top |
Posted over 3 years ago All nurses in New York State have been mandated to take the seasonal flu and H1N1 flu vaccine. Some facilities have said take the vaccine or lose your job. What would you do? |
|
509 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago take the vaccine. the flu is no big deal till it kills ya. i am going to wait a few extra months before taking the H1N1 and review more literature re those who have already recieved that vaccine and their side effects. |
|
10 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago New York nurses don't have the wait and see option that you have. They will be the ones to test out the new vaccine to make it safer for you. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Forcing the vaccine is wrong; People that are forced to take the vaccine, are going to be more likely to have 'side effects'. They'll be looking for every ache and pain to blame on the vaccine. Then the public will get alarmed and start freaking out, because those that were 'forced' to take the vaccine are all being interviewed on MSNBC explaining how now they have ongoing leg pains, headaches, unexplained rashes. It will be mass hysteria. I took the flu vaccine last week. I want the H1N1 vaccine when it comes out, so don't spoil it for me. |
|
Account Removed -5 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago This vaccine has been tested on large pools of volunteers. It appears the side effects are comparable to those with the "normal" annual flu vaccines. In 1976 the goverment freaked about "swine flu" and rolled out a vaccine that had a very short (if any) testing period. More than a few people developed Guillain Barre as a result of this vaccine. However, the Hepatitis B Recombinant vaccine is used on millions of people at present. You probably have had that series. My mother was a community health nurse for IHS on the Navajo reservation when she began that series. After the first injection she developed a low grade fever and aches in joints etc. These symptoms subsided and she correctly attributed the symptoms to side effects of the injection. However, after her next scheduled injection she began to develop more serious side effects and had to be transferred to the UNM Hospital and Medical Center in Albuquerque. She had some difficulty breathing and some noted neuro deficits in both her fine and gross motor skills. After a battery of exams it was determined she had Guillain Barre. While there was no direct proof at the moment that the vaccine had caused the syndrome the doctors there advised her to not continue the series at that point. It took almost a year for the symptoms to disappear. By then it was determined that there was a chance of developing GBS from the series and information as to such is now contained in the literature. I took the swine flu injection in 1976 and suffered no ill effects other than having less patience with idiots, which shows through here on other topic posts. But I would not be afraid to take this series and am planning to submit to the same request here at my work and take the shots. |
|
24 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Mr Brown, The story about your mother scares me, and I hate to admit it but mostly it scares me financially. I am an RN in NY and I work at the county hospital. I am not sure why but I don't put into NYS disability, so I cannot collect it if needed. I also was young and stupid and didn't sign up for the supplemental disability that was offered to me. So if I do develop complications from a vaccine I would not get by choice, and have symptoms like your mothers I would not be able to work. After my 2 months of PTO I have accumulated were over what would I do if I still had the symptoms your mom had, like difficulty breathing and noted neuro defects? I wouldn't be able to be a floor nurse like I am now. How would I pay my bills? I have also read that the side effects seem to be like the regular annual flu shot, but I am just plain scared. I have no children, and if it does have some long lasting effects on me could it effect my chances at healthy offspring? Don't get me wrong, I don't want to die of the swine flu, but I just dont agree with the way this is going. The law seems to have been passed at the end of August...I am not glued to news channels but my BF is and I didn't hear about it until rumors started circulating at work. And at my work they are not doing much to educate people or help them with any concerns. If you look on the NYS dept of health website about the " Health Care personnel Vaccination Requirements" http://www.health.state.ny.us/regulations/emergency/docs/2009-08-13_health_care_personnel_influenza_vaccination_requirements.pdf
I have alot to say but am not good at long posts. Please just look at this and tell me how you guys feel. One other thing that bugs me it that it seems as if this mandate states that from here on out health care workers will have to get an annual flu shot, not just for this year when we're so scared about the swine flu. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago If you get the flu, you can also develop GB. I would think that if you became disabled as a direct provable link to a vaccine, that it would fall under workmans comp. Additionally, there is a national vaccine fund, that you can apply to for assistance http://www.hrsa.gov/vaccinecompensation/VIC_Trust_Fund.htm Vaccine Injury Compensation Trust Fund The Vaccine Injury Compensation Trust Fund (Trust Fund) provides funding for the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) to compensate vaccine-related injury or death claims for covered vaccines administered on or after October 1, 1988. The Trust Fund is funded by a $0.75 excise tax on each dose of vaccine purchased (i.e., each disease prevented in a dose of vaccine). For example, the excise tax imposed on a dose of trivalent influenza vaccine is $0.75 because it prevents one disease, whereas the excise tax imposed on a dose of the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine is $2.25 because prevents three diseases. The taxable vaccines have also been recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) for routine administration to children. The Department of Treasury collects the excise taxes, and oversees and manages the investing activities for the Trust Fund. As of January 31, 2007, the Trust Fund balance was nearly $2.5 billion. The Trust Fund monthly reports are available on the Treasury’s Bureau of Public Debt Website |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Adult Claims After Influenza Vaccination Are adults who think that they have been injured after receiving trivalent influenza vaccines eligible to file claims with the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP)? Yes. An otherwise eligible person (who may be a child or an adult) who receives a trivalent influenza vaccine in the U.S. within the applicable time limits would be eligible to apply for compensation under the VICP even if the vaccine administered is licensed by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) exclusively for adults.
This answer reflects the position of the United States Department of Health and Human Services on the topics addressed. This answer does not create or confer any rights for or on any person and does not operate to bind the Department or the public. The ultimate decision about the scope of the statutes authorizing the VICP is within the authority of the United States Court of Federal Claims, which is responsible for resolving claims for compensation under the VICP
|
|
Account Removed -5 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Reading the PDF of the NY regs you posted it is clear that it is required. Without going off on that tangent I will say this is another reason nurses need to unionize. However, back to the vaccine. My arm swells up in a reaction to the annual flu vaccinations but otherwise I only get the normal aches and slightly elevated temp for a few hours. Despite my mother's experience I have completed 2 rounds of Hep B vaccinations, Hep A vaccination and will get both of these flu shots. As for your lack of disability - can't you modify your plan during open enrollment periods? I'm in Texas but even here we have the opportunity twice a year to modify our selections. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Gee, Mr Brown were you in Jersey in 76? We had massive swine vaccine centers. They had the flu 'guns' sending people through the line. I was 12, and went with my parents. I remember thinking 'holy cow' there is a huge amount of people here. We all had the swine flu vaccine (and no ill effects for us). |
|
Account Removed -5 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago No I was with Albuquerque Ambulance Company as an EMT-A. We lined up like fish and got the shots. Nothing ever happened to me or any of the other guys at work either. And I didn't get the swine flu, just ended up acting like one once in awhile. |
|
509 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago i think i will get the H1N1 shot as soon as its avail here at my hospital. i was going to wait but i found out recently that i also recieved the swine fu shot back in 1976 so i guess i will live to see another day. i don't want my peers in New York to be alone . Go you tough new yorkers!!!! |
|
2 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago My hospital in Chicago is mandating for staff to get the flu and H1N1 vaccine. I received my first flu shot since 1990 and did not have any side affects. Thank God! The H1N1 vaccines will be available in about two weeks. I am still questioning whether I will get it or sign the opt out release form. But I am highly considering. I would like for it to be out a little longer before I get it to see any side effects. |
|
54 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Ido not agree with people being forced to take the H1N1 flu shot. Especially since I have a child who was diagnosed with Guillain Barre Syndrome at the age of 5. He is now 24 years old but we have been told for years that he can't take the flu shot because it will kill him. I do not want this to happen. Has anyone Ever taken into consideration those for whom it is dangerous to take it? |
|
54 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Ido not agree with people being forced to take the H1N1 flu shot. Especially since I have a child who was diagnosed with Guillain Barre Syndrome at the age of 5. He is now 24 years old but we have been told for years that he can't take the flu shot because it will kill him. I do not want this to happen. Has anyone Ever taken into consideration those for whom it is dangerous to take it? |
|
24 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Thank you Kittyrn and mr brown for your responses. The more I think about it the less the shot bothers me, but being forced. If you read the regs there is a few pages being devoted to the cost for hospitals to vaccinate their workers and it states multiple times that the decrease in sick time will far outweigh the cost of vaccinations. If the state is looking to increase the rate of vaccinations among helathcare workers how about trying some incentives?? I bet you could double the amount of people who get the vaccine by paying them. Especially with the holidays coming up, if you paid people 100 bucks for each shot it would still be less than the cost of one sick day. (Well for me as an RN, in a hospital in NY) Healthcare workers are educated, reasonable people and we could work together for the comon goals of decreasing the spread of the flu and keeping our patients and ourselves safe. You don't have to force us. |
|
453 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Sorry, but no job has the right to force a vaccination on you. If there was proof that there were no side effects, that may be one thing, but, I've heard that H1N1 can cause Gilliam -Barre syndrome. Sorry, but if that's a possibilty, then nurses should have a right to choose whether or not thay want the shot. I myself have decided I will probably not get the vaccine. The age groups at risk are children. I've heard of parents refusing to immunize their children b/c of studies that it may cause autism. Why should a hospital be allowed to make that decision for a nurse? This a violation of someone's rights, and I was shocked when I read this article in my nurseweek publication. As Mr. Brown has stated, this should be one of the many reasons why nurses should unionize to protect themselves. There is power in numbers. Claire Kruszka |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago For the record; I've taken care of 2 patients that had GB, and both got it from the flu and not a vaccination. GB can come from vaccinations, but it also comes from the flu. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/guillain-barre-syndrome/DS00413/DSECTION=causes Mayo Clinic ; causes of guillain barre; My thought is this, if you get GB from the flu shot, you were probably going to get it right from the flu anyway. |
|
Account Removed -33 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Well, I will take it this year - I took the regular flu vaccines every year, and ate the sugar cubes in the early 1960's (ha! ask an older person). No side effects from anything for me... As far as "can the hospital force you?" - well, I guess they don't want employees getting sick and being out for a week or two. So yes, unless you have a contract, they can "force" prophylactic health measures on you. Could a union help? Maybe, but I've belonged to Nurses' Unions that were terribly ineffective. Women are difficult to unionize (don't yell at me! I was a union shop steward and Vice President in a mostly-female union! God bless them, but they are hard to organize and unionize!)
|
|
28 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I would never take the shot, nobody can force me too. I have never taken the regular flu shot and have not had the flu since 1977. If you have the antibody from the 1976 swine flu, this strain is not as virulent and you do not need it. The Govt is just trying to force people to do things. What a crappy Marxist, sociolistic society we live in. I liked it when we had freedom of choice. You get sick you stay home.... |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Here's my problem with people, especially health care workers NOT taking the flu shot. I have a grand neice that struggled with ALL for several years, and thanks to intensive intrathecal chemotherapy, she is alive and well. Her whole immune system was shut down...additionally she couldn't get routine childhood vaccinations. How many chemo patients, have prodromal nurses passed in the elevator, the hall, or down at the cafeteria. It's our job to protect those that are sick. Any infection can kill a cancer patient. Poor Megan couldn't even be taken to Wal-mart for fear of passing or touching anything that was potentially infective. I don't care if you get sick with the flu, but how many people as a healthcare worker do you expose to potentially murderous viruses, because you refuse to get vaccinated. When you are prodromal, you aren't home, you are working. |
|
28 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Kittyrn says ...
That's why handwashing and personal hygiene are so important. I know that there are a lot of people in the health care field that do not practice this, but it doesn't mean that I would have to be forced to do something I do not think is right. If a health care worker and a bunch of them would get sick from the shot, then who would take care of the patients??? Not everyone gets ill from the shot, but a lot of people do not tolerate it well. So, they just don't have a job? |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago Just make sure you do handwashing after everytime that you touch your own nose or mouth (even before going to cafeteria or getting on the elevator). If you are prodromal, you don't even know you are sick. |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago If a health care worker and a bunch of them would get sick from the shot, then who would take care of the patients??? Not everyone gets ill from the shot, but a lot of people do not tolerate it well. You understand that more people will get the flu from not having the shot, and it's not the other way around? So who's going to take care of the patients when all the healthcare workers are out with the flu?
|
|
453 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I took the regular flu shot, and my immune system must have been weak, b/c I experienced a sore throat, h/a ,and generalized achiness a few days after recieving it. I had to call in. I usually tell pt's who are already having cold/flu like symptoms to forgo the shot until they are feeling better. My facility requires us to offer the at risk population flu and pneumonia shots when they are being admitted. I had an elderly lady coughing up her lungs last Friday, and I recommended she wait.She didn't need to add to her misery. Claire Kruszka |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I took the H1n1 vaccine yesterday. Nothing but a sore arm. Hundreds of us at my hospital, have already recieved the shot or nasal spray. My kids are going to get the shot as well through the school system. |
|
509 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago got flu shot last sat . got tickle in my throat and sore arm but tickle lasted only 2-3 hours arm hurt for about 4 she gave the shot too high up on the deltoid and in the middle not back 1/3 ! anyways its over and im still breathin whoohoo! wish my kids could get it at school. |
|
278 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I'm proud to declare that I am now administering H1N1 vaccines for the county of SD here in SoCal. Of course it is a personal choice to decide whether or not to get the shot (or nasal spray) unless it comes to health care... Who would be left to care for the sick if we all end up missing work? or spread the virus further? I highly advise getting the "dead" virus to everyone! -Angela--'--,--{@ |
|
Account Removed -1 posts back to top |
| Posted over 3 years ago I took the shot over the nasal spray. On our kids consent forms, I picked shot over nasal spray. I was happier with that although I'm sure my kids weren't. |

Answer 